Increased physical effort overrides the potentially deleterious effects of resource depletion following self-control
Journal Title: Journal of Science and Cycling - Year 2014, Vol 3, Issue 2
Abstract
Background: Long duration cycling events require riders to maintain concentration and self-control over lengthy periods, for example, listening to race plans and/or eve-dropping on conversations of other riders whilst maintaining pace and bike control. Self-control is the deliberate effort to override a dominant response such as an emotion or thought with a response perceived to benefit goal attainment. Evidence suggests that self-control is an effortful process that draws upon both physiological and psychological resources (Gailliot et al., 2007: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 92 (2), 325–336). Thus, if effortful self-control draws upon physiological resources, then it could hamper endurance performance which utilises the same physiological substrates. However, recent research has questioned this explanation suggesting self-control might be more about resource allocation (Beedie & Lane, 2012: Personality and Social Psychology Review, 16(2):143-53). Purpose: The purpose of the present study was to examine the effects of doing self-control tasks on cycle performance and emotion regulation. In a dual-task design, one task (bicycle ride) was personally meaningful and a second task (Stroop task) had unknown personal meaning. We hypothesised that by recruiting participants to a task that was personally meaningful, individuals’ emotions would act as a signal to mobilise resources to overcome the potentially deleterious effects of resource-depletion deriving from the Stroop task. We predicted that performance on the Stroop task would deteriorate as participants re-allocated resources to the primary task. Methods: 43 participants were randomly assigned to one of two conditions: an experimental condition comprising two self-control tasks performed consecutively and a control condition in which two tasks were performed consecutively but only one required self-control. The procedure was as follows: 1) Stroop task 2) Bicycle ride; 3) Stroop task; 4) Bicycle ride, 5) Stroop task. A modified version of the classic Stroop colour-word task was employed using shapes and colours. In the (non-depleting) control condition, shapes were presented in their respective shape and colour (e.g., the word ‘‘green’’ and shape “triangle” was presented in green ink and as a triangle). In the (depleting) experimental condition, the word and ink colour was incongruent with the shape (e.g., the words “green triangle” appeared below a red square in red font colour). Participants rated their emotions before and after both bicycle rides. They were all asked to rate how important it was to perform well. Results: Cycle performance results indicated performance was fastest in the second trial (194 + 48s vs 212 + 45s) than the first trial (213 + 39s vs 230 + 41s) with no significant differences between the control and experimental group, hence suggesting the first self-control did not impair performance. Improved performance was matched with increased heart rate across trials for both the control (130 + 19bpm vs 136 + 19bpm) and experimental groups (125 + 22 vs 133 + 21bpm). In contrast, the rate of improvement for the Stroop was significantly faster among the control group compared to the experimental group across all three tasks (18.38 + 5.27 vs 24.17 + 5.67s; 17.54 + 4.86 vs 23.12 + 4.51; 16.39 + 4.70 vs 22.0.8 + 3.25). Discussion: In support of our hypothesis, bicycle performance improved following completion of the Stroop task. In contrast to previous findings, final Stroop performance also improved suggesting that there could be a transfer effect. Our findings are consistent with recent research that has argued that cognitive and affective theory (Beedie & Lane, 2012) provides a better fit to deficits in self-control than the strength model (Gailliot et al., 2007). Conclusion: These findings provide experimental evidence that self-control ability is temporarily impaired following a separate, unrelated self-control task. However, if participants are sufficiently motivated to perform well, then increased physical effort may improve self-control behaviour and this appears to transfer across tasks.
Authors and Affiliations
C Fullerton| University of Wolverhampton, United Kingdom., AM Lane| University of Wolverhampton, United Kingdom., TJ Devonport| University of Wolverhampton, United Kingdom.
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP2849
- DOI -
- Views 359
- Downloads 24
Orthotic insoles show effects on knee kinematics during pedaling in recreational cyclists
Orthotic insoles in cycling shoes are an intervention used to correct pedaling mechanics in riders, which has received little attention in the literature. This study was designed to test the hypothesis that the use of or...
Wind speed, wind yaw and the aerodynamic drag acting on a bicycle and rider
A large portion of a cyclist’s power is consumed by air drag. Opposing force power meters measure air drag with a wind sensor. In cross winds the bicycle and rider experience a different air drag than that informed by a...
Development of a multi-directional rating test method for bicycle frame stiffness
The methods for determining the bicycle frame stiffness exist in many forms. Because the stiffness measuring method is not standardized, each bicycle magazine or bicycle constructer uses his own test configuration. This...
Torso and facial/head pre-cooling and anaerobic cycling performance in a hot and humid environment
It has been demonstrated that cooling athletes before (pre-cooling) enabled a higher level of power output developed during exercise (Tyler et al., 2015, British Journal of Sports Medicine, 47, 7-13), increased thermal c...
Analysis of gender policies of the Spanish cycling and triathlon federations from the point of view of representative athletes and expert technicians
The Spanish National Sports Council, through its program “Women and Sport” (published in the Decree Pre/525/2005), implements specific entities in Spanish cycling and triathlon federations with the aim of promoting the s...