Philosophy in science – a case study of the reception of the Special and the General Theory of Relativity in Kraków and Lwów before 1925
Journal Title: Studia Historiae Scientiarum - Year 2016, Vol 15, Issue
Abstract
A centenary of Einstein’s General Theory of Relativity brings forward some questions with regard to the impact of Einstein’s theory on philosophy. This theory, and the chronologically earlier Special Theory of Relativity, have had many important philosophical implications. In Poland they provoked interesting philosophical discussions before WWII. The history of those discussions reveals numerous noteworthy facts concerning the relationships between mathematics, physics and philosophy. A case study of the reception of the Special and General Theory of Relativity in Kraków and Lwów before 1925 focuses on the peculiar specificity of exact sciences and philosophy in Polish Galicia. The concept of “philosophy in science” coined by Michael Heller is particularly suitable for describing this specificity. The article begins with a short overview of the early reception of the Special Theory of Relativity in Kraków. Next, it shows how the discussions during the 10th and 11th Congresses of Polish Physicians and Natural Scientists (Lwów 1907, Kraków 1911) influenced the reception of the STR. What is also discussed are the roots of the specificity of the reception in Lwów, i.e. the influence of the considerations about the foundations of mechanics and a public philosophical debate around Einstein’s theories. In order to demonstrate how different the reception of these theories was in Kraków, a description is provided of a methodological debate between S. Zaremba and T. Banachiewicz. Some notes are also added about the concurrent styles of philosophy of science (philosophy of nature). The article ends with conclusions about the specificity of Kraków’s and Lwów’s styles of philosophy in science. This study reveals that in this period Einstein’s theories significantly stimulated philosophical considerations in Poland. These considerations have become an important supplement to the scientific activity in Kraków and Lwów.
Authors and Affiliations
Paweł Polak
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP182191
- DOI 10.4467/23921749SHS.16.010.6153
- Views 60
- Downloads 0
Scientific conference dedicated to the memory of Professor Andrzej Gawroński in Przemyśl
The author gave to print the report of the scientific “Andrzej Gawroński (1885–1927) - a linguist and scholar.” It was organized by the Society of Friends of Science in Przemyśl, Juliusz Słowacki High School No. 1 in Prz...
OSIĄGNIĘCIA I ZNACZENIE LWOWSKIEJ SZKOŁY MATEMATYCZNEJ
A SKETCH ON THE CURRENT DEBATE ON SCIENTOMETRICS AND BIBLIOMETRICS VERSUS THE FORGOTTEN SCIENCE OF SCIENCE
In the debate on scientometrics and bibliometrics, taking place in Poland in the last 25 years, a very serious methodical and methodological mistake has been committed by neglecting the reflection about the science of sc...
NIE WSZYSTKO ZACZĘŁO SIĘ OD BUNSENA I KIRCHHOFFA – NIEZNANE WĄTKI WCZESNEJ HISTORII SPEKTROSKOPU OPTYCZNEGO (1810–1860)
Beyond the center: Sciences in Central and Eastern Europe and their histories An interview with Professor Michael Gordin conducted by Jan Surman
What is special about sciences in Central and Eastern Europe? What are the obstacles for writing histories of science done beyond metropoles? Is this science different than the science in the centers and what makes it so...