Science and the Religious Rhetorics of the Ineffable: A Comparison Between Two Cosmoses
Journal Title: Res Rhetorica - Year 2017, Vol 4, Issue 2
Abstract
Since Thomas Kuhn’s revolutionary look at the social construction of science, research into the rhetorics of science has shown how science is a persuasive form of discourse, rarely as transparent and self-evident as is often understood. Rhetorical studies have taken this cue to examine how science is constructed through available means beyond mere logic. Arguably, the resurgence of creationist beliefs in political discourse has brought on a new impetus in science to persuade the “hearts and minds” of the American population, inspiring Neil deGrasse Tyson’s remaking of Carl Sagan’s 1980 documentary Cosmos. Using Rudolph Otto’s, The Idea of the Holy, this article will define religion as an ineffable experience that creates “creature-consciousness,” or a sense of awe and insufficiency towards something outside the self, while also producing a sense of identification or “oneness.” The ineffable experience is core to the public making of science, just as the ineffable experience plays a defining role in religions. Though science and religion are often seen as mutually exclusively (sometimes in opposition), identifying the ineffable experience as a shared ground can provide opportunities for science and religion to dialogue in new ways.
Authors and Affiliations
Lance L. Cummings
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP262177
- DOI 10.29107/rr2017.2.2
- Views 83
- Downloads 0
Reakcje werbalne odbiorców porady internetowej a perswazyjność przekazu poradnikowego Verbal reactions of Internet advice receivers versus persuasiveness of advice message
The article analyzes verbal reactions of advice receivers on the Internet in terms of the impact of reactions on the persuasiveness of the advice message. The research material comes from two websites: milionporad.pl and...
Staropolskie mowy winszujące narodzin potomka. Rekonesans
This study is dedicated to the issue of Old-Polish oratory genethliac variant, that is congratulatory speech delivered on occasion of offspring’s birth – in either theoretical and practical aspect. The main part of the s...
Techniki perswazji w kampaniach 1% w Polsce – analiza wybranych przykładów
Kampanie społeczne służą nagłaśnianiu treści ważnych społecznie, stanowią również narzędzie nakłaniania odbiorców do przekazywania środków finansowych na konto wybranego podmiotu. Celem artykułu jest wskazanie środków pe...
Retoryka „czarnego marszu” na materiale haseł prezentowanych w przestrzeni publicznej
Artykuł stanowi próbę analizy retorycznej postulatów prezentowanych w przestrzeni publicznej podczas tzw. czarnego marszu, czyli demonstracji na rzecz obrony praw reprodukcyjnych polskich kobiet. Na podstawie zebranego m...
Rhetoric in Spain: an overview
In the paper, the author stresses the main trends in Spain in contemporary research in rhetoric, as well as the most influential authors, their international renown, the current major research projects and their theoreti...