A comparative analysis of the assessment results of the competence of technical experts by methods of analytic hierarchy process and with using the Rasch model
Journal Title: Восточно-Европейский журнал передовых технологий - Year 2018, Vol 3, Issue 3
Abstract
<p>Known scales (criteria) for assessing the competence of experts in the field of technical regulation using the method of analytical hierarchy process (AHP) and Rasch model are investigated. The main features of constructing the mathematical Rash model are presented. The results of the analysis of scales for assessing the competence of experts in the field of technical regulation on a specific example of questioned specialists in measurement of time and frequency were considered. The results were processed using the specialized software “Competence MAI 1.1” (Ukraine) and MINISTEP 4.0.1 (USA).</p><p>A comparative analysis of the results was carried out in order to determine the effectiveness of the assessment scales. The obtained results showed the possibility of applying the Rasch model for the analysis of the scale of expert assessment in the field of technical regulation. The analysis of the results obtained on the multidimensional Rasch model showed that the chosen criteria scale for experts corresponds to the requirements set by the Rash model. The obtained measurement data for this model allow you to calculate the established statistics for both the criteria and for the evaluated experts.</p><p>A comparative analysis of the results obtained with the use of AHP and Rasch model showed convergence, suitability and correlation of the obtained values for experts. Only two out of twenty one (9.5 %) evaluated experts have data that are unsuitable for the analysis by the Rasch model, which indicates a low level of competence. AHP to a lesser extent allows for the consideration of less competent experts than with the use of the Rash model. This is evidenced by a lower coefficient of competence for the AHP than in the application of the Rasch model. AHP and Rasch model should be used in various fields of activity as a useful tool for comparative assessment of the competence of technical experts on the basis of objective data according to established criteria.</p>
Authors and Affiliations
Oleh Velychko, Tetyana Gordiyenko
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP527966
- DOI 10.15587/1729-4061.2018.131459
- Views 62
- Downloads 0
Development of the PID-neurocontroller to compensate for the impact of damages and degradation of induction motor on operation of the electric drive system
<p><em>In order to synthesize adaptive control systems over asynchronous electric drive that includes a motor with defects or degradation, we proposed a structure and developed an algorithm for training a PID-neurocontro...
Analysis of the properties of antifriction composites based on aluminum alloy's grinding waste
<p>We developed antifriction composites based on regenerated grinding waste of AM4.5Kd aluminum alloy with the addition of МоS<sub>2 </sub>solid lubricant intended for work in contact pairs of post-printing machines, suc...
Development of a method for optimizing operation of centrifugal gas superchargers under conditions of uncertainty
<p>A problem of development of a method of optimal control of operation of natural gas superchargers by a criterion which both minimizes fuel gas consumption and takes into account power of nitrogen oxide emissions into...
Development of the method for geometric modeling of S-shaped camber line of the profile of an axial compressor blade
The method for geometric modeling of the S-shaped camber line of the profile of an axial compressor blade, which is a compound curve formed from three sections, was developed. Each of these sections is modeled in the nat...
Analysis of influence of technical features of a pidcontroller implementation on the dynamics of automated control system
<p>Under conditions of intensification and maximization of production profitability, a problem of regulation, optimization and improvement of the structure of automatic control systems arises. To date, there are many top...