A comparative analysis of the assessment results of the competence of technical experts by methods of analytic hierarchy process and with using the Rasch model
Journal Title: Восточно-Европейский журнал передовых технологий - Year 2018, Vol 3, Issue 3
Abstract
<p>Known scales (criteria) for assessing the competence of experts in the field of technical regulation using the method of analytical hierarchy process (AHP) and Rasch model are investigated. The main features of constructing the mathematical Rash model are presented. The results of the analysis of scales for assessing the competence of experts in the field of technical regulation on a specific example of questioned specialists in measurement of time and frequency were considered. The results were processed using the specialized software “Competence MAI 1.1” (Ukraine) and MINISTEP 4.0.1 (USA).</p><p>A comparative analysis of the results was carried out in order to determine the effectiveness of the assessment scales. The obtained results showed the possibility of applying the Rasch model for the analysis of the scale of expert assessment in the field of technical regulation. The analysis of the results obtained on the multidimensional Rasch model showed that the chosen criteria scale for experts corresponds to the requirements set by the Rash model. The obtained measurement data for this model allow you to calculate the established statistics for both the criteria and for the evaluated experts.</p><p>A comparative analysis of the results obtained with the use of AHP and Rasch model showed convergence, suitability and correlation of the obtained values for experts. Only two out of twenty one (9.5 %) evaluated experts have data that are unsuitable for the analysis by the Rasch model, which indicates a low level of competence. AHP to a lesser extent allows for the consideration of less competent experts than with the use of the Rash model. This is evidenced by a lower coefficient of competence for the AHP than in the application of the Rasch model. AHP and Rasch model should be used in various fields of activity as a useful tool for comparative assessment of the competence of technical experts on the basis of objective data according to established criteria.</p>
Authors and Affiliations
Oleh Velychko, Tetyana Gordiyenko
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP527966
- DOI 10.15587/1729-4061.2018.131459
- Views 67
- Downloads 0
Material selection for the mesh electrode of electrochromic device based on Ni(OH)2
<p class="1">In this study, we propose changes to the cell design in order to reduce the cost of electrochromic devices. The modification lies in the replacement of the second electrochromic layer along with its conducti...
Development of structures of the aircraft fire alarm system by means of nested modules
<p>Optimization of structures of information management systems is determined by the choice of such a functional structure that would ensure high reliability of information. When creating complex systems, there is the pr...
An impact of the ladle lining on the refining of reinforced steel when blowing with powders
<p>When refining steel by blowing powders, the ladle lining material plays a serious role. The dependency graphs of the degree of desulfurization on the consumption of silicocalcium powder during blowing in ladles lined...
Prediction of chatter stability in turning
A new technology for predicting chatter in turning, based on simulation of the cutting process in time and frequency domains using the Nyquist diagram has been developed. The cutting process is presented as carried out i...
Development of the technology for the spectral noise control of the vibration conditions of offshore platforms
<p>Because of the shortcomings in both control and diagnostic systems, the accident rate for offshore oil and gas extracting facilities remains unreasonably high. Accidents are often caused by the errors resulting from t...