A Criticism of Edwin O. Reischauer’s Pronouncements on Ancient Korea-Japan Relations
Journal Title: International Journal of Korean History - Year 2011, Vol 16, Issue 1
Abstract
This paper aims to examine the ancient Korea-Japan relations as mentioned in the book entitled The Japanese, (Tokyo: Charles E. Tuttle, 1977). The book was written by Edwin O. Reischauer, University Professor at Harvard, who was United States Ambassador to Japan from 1961 to 1966. The book reflects the distorted view of Japanese historians who misrepresent the history of ancient Korea-Japan relations. He insists that there were semi-autonomous tribal units of natural growth in Japan and the ancient burial mounds belonged to privileged Japanese aristocracy. But they were proven to be the tombs of the influential immigrants from the Korean Peninsula to Japanese islands. Notwithstanding that Prince Shotoku was a fictitious figure, Reischauer maintains that he was a historical person who founded the Horyuji Temple. Also he declares that the Japanese absorbed Tang culture and civilization extensively and single-mindedly. But from before the sixth century until the end of the eighth century, Japan was under the dominion of Korea-Baekje (Paekche) in pre-668 years and Unified Silla after that. And it is now an open secret that massive influxes of immigrants with highly advanced civilization and culture from Korea settled in the Japanese islands among unlettered natives living off fish and marine products. They can be proven to the accounts in the Nihonshoki on Korean immigrants settling in the Japanese islands to found a new state. And ancient place-names of Japan were named after Korean kingdoms, most of which were renamed in recent ages, only a few still remaining.
Authors and Affiliations
Jae-seok Choi
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP26359
- DOI -
- Views 451
- Downloads 30
Textbook Inspection and Censorship in Korea during the Protectorate Period: A Study of Inspection Copies of Textbooks Compiled by the Young Korean Academy
Established during the Japanese protectorate period, the censorship system lasted throughout the colonial period as well. Therefore it is necessary to examine such censorship system as part of Japan’s colonization policy...
The Korean through a Prism of the Soviet-Japanese Relations(1920-1930)
After clearing of the Far East interventionist in 1922-1923 the main task of the young Soviet state was the establishment of diplomatic relations between Moscow and Tokyo. Representatives of the USSR and Japan had been s...
The Sino-Japanese War (1894-1895) : Japanese National Integration and Construction of the Korean “Other”
The significance of the Sino-Japanese War (1894-1895) for the evolution of the international relations in East Asia in the twentieth century as well as the unfolding of national histories in China, Japan and Korea has be...
The Great Wall as Perilous Frontier for the Mongols in 16th Century: Reconsidering Nomadic-Sedentary Relations in Premodern Inner Asia
The existing scholarship in nomadic-sedentary relations has focused on the raids and invasions by nomads against agricultural society, and has attempted to seek internal reasons for this within the nomadic society. Inter...
Imagining Ritual and Cultic Practice in Koguryŏ Buddhism
Due to the scarcity of extant source materials, the ritual and devotional practices of Koguryŏ Buddhism cannot be known in any great detail, but they probably had much in common with those practiced in Northern China. Me...