A Criticism On G.H.A. Juynboll Perspectives about Mutawatir Hadith
Journal Title: International Journal of Academic Research in Business and Social Sciences - Year 2019, Vol 8, Issue 7
Abstract
The hadith scholars argue that mutawâtir hadith is guaranteed originally from the Prophet. All mutawâtir hadiths are acceptable to be used as proof of Islamic teaching without having to examine their narrators. In contrast to the scholars of hadith, G.H.A. Juynboll with his common link theory, has been doubted the existence of the mutawâtir. He questions this category of hadith starting from its definition that he values as full-rated issues, it is developed recklessly and never free from ambiguity, as well as formulated with variety of changes that are not simple. According to him, the terms of mutawâtir is often used loosely or even incorrectly. Their criterias are useless, unless one criteria namely the criteria regarding the condition of transmitters at different levels of isnâd. The criteria of mutawâtir lafziy is a historiographical criteria that can never be applied and mutawâtir ma’nawiy only occurs in a limited number of hadiths with no standard criteria, unorganized as well as unstructured clearly. This paper attempts to criticize the concept and opinion of Juynboll about mutawâtir hadiths focusing on three areas; their definition, their criterias, and the number of isnâd lines in the mutawâtir hadiths
Authors and Affiliations
M. Ag. Idri, Rohaizan Baru
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP566146
- DOI 10.6007/IJARBSS/v8-i7/4521
- Views 61
- Downloads 0
Utilizing Music and Songs to Promote Student Engagement in ESL Classrooms
One of the main challenges English language teachers face in their daily classes is to find creative ways of sustaining their students’ interest in language learning, which can often be perceived as dull and tedious. Mus...
Effective Academic Leadership: Key Aspects of Leader Behavior in Higher Education
Currently, effective leadership plays an important role in improving the context of higher education. Policy makers, leaders, and university staff considered the effective leadership as determining a factor for managemen...
The Development of Housing Model Constructs to Measure the Well-Being of the Residents in Peri Urban Area of Klang-Langat Valley Extended Metropolitan Region, Malaysia
This article aims to develop and analyse a model for the well-being of the people living in the peri urban area based on the housing constructs. A total of 1000 respondents consisting of heads of household living in the...
The Development Model Of Football Coaches Specific Strength And Conditioning Knowledge: Application towards Youth Women’s Football Players in the Selangor State Sports School
The purpose of this study is to identify the level of knowledge among coaches of youth women’s football of the Selangor State Sports School (SSS) and the issues and challenges faced in the implementation of strength and...
Effect of Teamwork, Employee Empowerment and Training on Employee Performance
Employee performance is considered as the main and most important HR practice in every organization as it is the key through which organizations achieve their ultimate goals and they can only achieve productivity and eff...