A Gloss for the Judgement of the Supreme Court Dated November 23,2012, File Ref. No. IV CSK 598/12
Journal Title: Roczniki Nauk Prawnych - Year 2017, Vol 0, Issue 1
Abstract
The presented gloss discusses the judgement file ref. no. IV CSK 598/12 dated November 23, 2012, issued by the Supreme Court concerning the possibility of recognizing the acquirer of a bankrupt undertaking as its legal successor, and the impact of the amount of contractual payments made to date on the validity of a decision issued in connection with the amount of remuneration for the non-contractual use of the leased thing. The Supreme Court underscores that the disposal of an undertaking of a bankrupt company in the course of bankruptcy proceedings with a winding-up option gives rise to events appropriate for universal succession. The position indicating lack of effect of legal succession on the part of the acquirer concerns the case of acquisition of a bankrupt undertaking which retains its legal existence after bankruptcy proceedings are over. However, this does not apply to the special situation connected with the disposal of an entire undertaking of the company in the course of completed bankruptcy proceedings. The Supreme Court found that in assessing the validity of the contested contractual provision, the extent of the contractual performances made to date in the form of lease payments, cannot play a decisive role. The disproportion in payments cannot be contravene the principles of social intercourse. The presented gloss accepts the arguments of the judgement of the Supreme Court; however, attention is drawn to the principle of proportionality between creditors and a debtor, as well as the import of Article 5 of the Civil Code.
Authors and Affiliations
Adam Zarzycki
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP669144
- DOI 10.18290/rnp.2017.27.1-9en
- Views 115
- Downloads 0
Powers of the Legislative Body of a Local Government Unit Concerning the Grant Of Subsidies in Light of the New Act on the Financing of Educational Tasks
As of January 1, 2018, the provisions of the new Act on the financing of education tasks came into force, whereby the statutory legislator authorised the legislative bodies of local government units to, among others, det...
The Formation of the Concept of a Hermit, or an Anchorite, in the Light of the Latin Church Law Codification After the Second Vatican Council
The subject of the article is the formation of the concept of a hermit or an anchorite in the light of the codification of the Latin Church law after Vatican II. In canon 603 CIC/83, the legislator uses two terms of a he...
Directions of Change in the Regulation of the Notion of Insolvency under the Polish Bankruptcy Law
The study outlines three concepts of legal regulation of the concept of insolvency based on the pre-war bankruptcy law, the bankruptcy and reorganization law and the new bankruptcy law in force today. The aim is to captu...
Wpływ koncepcji good governance na sposób działania administracji publicznej w Polsce – zarys problematyki
Koncepcja „dobrego rządzenia” odzwierciedlona w przepisach prawnych modyfikuje charakter działania podmiotów administracji publicznej. Jest ona obecnie promowana przez instytucje międzynarodowe, w tym Unię Europejską, zw...
Znaczenie wskazania kwalifikacji prawnej czynu oraz jej zmiany w toku postępowania karnego dla realizacji przez oskarżonego prawa do obrony
W tekście przedstawiono problematykę dotyczącą wskazania przez oskarżyciela, w tym także przez oskarżyciela publicznego, kwalifikacji prawnej czynu oraz znaczenie tej czynności dla możliwości sprawowania przez oskarżoneg...