A Methodological Crisis in the WASH Sector: Crunching Numbers and Throwing Them over the Wall
Journal Title: Public Health Open Access - Year 2021, Vol 5, Issue 1
Abstract
Some pre-digital ‘Common Sense’ is urgently needed to salvage the WASH sector. A spate of recent Randomized Control Trials (RCTs) have shown negligible effect of improved water, safe sanitation and non-risk hygiene behaviour on health outcomes, prompting a methodological crisis amongst practitioners. Three different behaviour change methodologies, Community Led Total Sanitation (CLTS) routinely used to trigger improved sanitation, Social Marketing to promote hand washing, and the Community Health Club (CHC) approach to improve hygiene behaviour, have all shown through RCTs to have little impact on health, with much debate as to the reasons for such failure. When RCTs question the validity of such interventions, lives may be affected as funding is hard to justify. In one case at least, common sense prevailed, when Rwandan Ministry of Health, instead of aborting the Community Based Environmental Health Promotion Programme (CBEHPP) on the recommendation of the cRCT, chose instead to enhance it by including a substantial nutrition component with the rationale this would be essential if stunting as well as diarrhoea was to be controlled. There is increasing recognition that to achieve sustained health impact much more time is needed in WASH programmers than is normally available to inventions evaluated through most RCTs.
Authors and Affiliations
Waterkeyn J
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP755701
- DOI 10.23880/phoa-16000179
- Views 39
- Downloads 0
Comparative Analysis of Gender Based Violence Knowledge and Attitudes among HIV-Positive and HIV-Negative Youths in Zimbabwe
This study sought to investigate Knowledge and attitudes of gender based violence among HIV-positive and HIV-negative youths in Zimbabwe. A cross-sectional mixed method research design was employed in the study. This stu...
Medicare and Medicaid Unifying or Crushing?
Introduction: The increase in medical spending by the United States is unmatched in other developed countries, as evidenced by OECD analyses. The Medicare spending grew 4.5% to 646.2 billion, 20% of total NHE. The Medic...
Exploring the Perspectives of Healthcare Professionals Concerning the Use and Utility of the Hospital Gown to Develop Theoretically Informed Behaviour Change Interventions
The tenets of dignity, safety and privacy are potentially challenged when patients are required to remove their own clothes and wear the hospital gown for medical procedures. This study adopted a mixed method analysis in...
Gestational Diabetes Mellitus and Pandemic Covid-19: Where do we Stand?
Pregnant women with increasing blood glucose levels are identified as being more exposed to the severe effects of COVID-19 and advised to follow social distancing stringently. The COVID-19 pandemic has required rapid tra...
Neurological Complications of Hypertension: A Review Article
Hypertension (HTN) is a major cause of morbidity and mortality because of its complication like neuronal disease, coronary heart disease, cerebrovascular disease and renal disease. It is also known for the second most co...