Against the Grain and Over the Line: Reflections on Comparative Methodology
Journal Title: Religions - Year 2018, Vol 9, Issue 2
Abstract
This article distills theoretical arguments that I advance in Foreigners and Their Food, arguments relevant to a wide range of religious studies scholars. In addition, it makes the case for comparison as a method that sheds light not only on specific comparands and the class of data to which they belong but also on the very boundaries which the comparison transgresses. Through a comparison of Latin Christian and Shiʿi Islamic discourse about the impurity of religious foreigners, I illustrate methods by which religious authorities develop and transmit conceptions of foreigners. I then analyze this case study using Oliver Freiberger’s “Elements of a Comparative Methodology” while assessing the strengths and limitations of Freiberger’s methodical framework. I offer personal reflections on the process of conducting comparative scholarship, advice for those embarking on this demanding yet rewarding approach to the study of religion, and desiderata for further reflection on comparative methodology.
Authors and Affiliations
David M. Freidenreich
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP25912
- DOI https://doi.org/10.3390/rel9020044
- Views 346
- Downloads 11
An Exploration of Specialist Palliative Care Nurses’ Experiences of Providing Care to Hospice Inpatients from Minority Ethnic Groups—Implication for Religious and Spiritual Care
The aim of this research study was to gain an understanding of nurses’ experiences of providing care to patients from minority ethnic groups within the specialist palliative care inpatient unit of an Irish hospice. Fiv...
A European (German) View on Comparative Theology: Dialogue with My Own Past
For the last couple of years, particularly after the publication of the (German) book ―Comparative Theology‖ by Bernhold Reinhardt and Klaus von Stosch, there was a significant attentiveness of this subject amongst Ger...
Nurses’ Perceptions of Spirituality and Spiritual Care in Different Health Care Settings in the Netherlands
This paper shows similarities and differences in perceptions and competences regarding spirituality and spiritual care of nurses in different health care settings. Research on this specific topic is limited and can con...
The One and the Many in Bonaventure Exemplarity Explained
The category of exemplarity, which holds a central place in Bonaventure’s thought, is in many ways a certain type of solution to the problem of the many and the one. Bonaventure’s account of the relationship between th...
Pastoralism in Latin America: An Ensemble of Religious Governmental Technologies in Colonial Costa Rica
Based on a critical empirical application of Foucault’s concept of pastoralism and a genealogical research approach, this article suggests that the Catholic regime that operated in Costa Rica during the Spanish colonia...