Apekty normy - problem holistycznego ujęcia wzorca normatywnego w świetle myśli późnego Wittgensteina
Journal Title: Internetowy Magazyn Filozoficzny HYBRIS - Year 2019, Vol 1, Issue 44
Abstract
In Polish legal theory there is a generally accepted distinction between legal norms (normative standards) and legal provisions (independent editorial units of a legal text). One of the most developed theories of the interpretation of law, the derivative theory of M. Zieliński, however, also includes the postulate of the reconstruction of the entire legal system as one comprehensive norm (the so-called holistic approach) in the process of applying the law. This postulate stems mainly from assumptions regarding the adopted methods of interpretation. The holistic approach has often been criticized as inadequate in pragmatic terms, but the derivative theory has not yet been thoroughly modified in this respect. In this paper, I propose to apply Wittgenstein's concept of aspect perception as providing adequate conceptual framework to describe the mechanism of identifying relevant parts of the legal norm that deals with the pragmatic inadequacy of the holistic approach, but does not affect the core of the derivative theory of interpretation.
Authors and Affiliations
Wojciech Graboń
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP568143
- DOI -
- Views 83
- Downloads 0
Ocena trafności zarzutów przeciw ateizmowi semantycznemu Bohdana Chwedeńczuka
The article iś diverśe on two partś. In the firśt part, the author referś aśśumptionś of Bohdan Chweden czuk book, “Przekonania religijne” [Religiouś Beliefś] that waś devoted to juśtify the theśiś according to which rel...
"Cała matematyka to właściwie geometria". Poglądy Gottloba Fregego na podstawy matematyki po upadku logicyzmu
Gottlob Frege abandoned his logicist program after Bertrand Russell had discovered that some assumptions of Frege’s system lead to contradiction (so called Russell’s paradox). Nevertheless, he proposed a new attempt for...
Logicznie poprawny argument tu quoque
The argument tu quoque is widely called a logical fallacy. The aim of this study is to show, that this theorem is ill-considered. The text is focused on the analysis of various examples of tu quoque. This analysis leads...
Socjalizm jako hipertrofia indywidualizmu. Lwa Karsawina recepcja poglądów Karola Marksa na przykładzie rozważań na temat postępu
Lev Karsavin (1882-1952) on the views of Karl Marx (1818-1882) spoke indirectly, through analysis of socialism as a scientific theory, and then as the ideological doctrine, which determines, inter alia, the form of the S...
Niezrównoważenie w kryzysie
W czasach kryzysu Europy nadmierne koncentrowanie się na kwestiach rynkowych i gospodarczych w analizowaniu przyczyn i szukaniu rozwiązan wspo łczesnych problemo w wydaje mi się działaniem niedostatecznym. Co więcej, uwa...