Apekty normy - problem holistycznego ujęcia wzorca normatywnego w świetle myśli późnego Wittgensteina
Journal Title: Internetowy Magazyn Filozoficzny HYBRIS - Year 2019, Vol 1, Issue 44
Abstract
In Polish legal theory there is a generally accepted distinction between legal norms (normative standards) and legal provisions (independent editorial units of a legal text). One of the most developed theories of the interpretation of law, the derivative theory of M. Zieliński, however, also includes the postulate of the reconstruction of the entire legal system as one comprehensive norm (the so-called holistic approach) in the process of applying the law. This postulate stems mainly from assumptions regarding the adopted methods of interpretation. The holistic approach has often been criticized as inadequate in pragmatic terms, but the derivative theory has not yet been thoroughly modified in this respect. In this paper, I propose to apply Wittgenstein's concept of aspect perception as providing adequate conceptual framework to describe the mechanism of identifying relevant parts of the legal norm that deals with the pragmatic inadequacy of the holistic approach, but does not affect the core of the derivative theory of interpretation.
Authors and Affiliations
Wojciech Graboń
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP568143
- DOI -
- Views 82
- Downloads 0
Filozoficzne korzenie konfliktu między Marksem a Bakuninem
This essay explores the underlying philosophical differences separating Marxism and anarchism by examining the specific philosophies of Marx and Bakunin. The conflicting philosophical foundations of these two philosopher...
Znaczenie pojęcia miłości w filozofii Fryderyka Nietzschego
This paper presents the meaning of the concept of love in philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche. Love in its proper form is a kind of intoxication (Rausch), therefore it is an expression of feeling of power. Besides there ar...
Marks jako fałszerz tradycji socjalistycznej. Diagnoza Gieorgija Fiedotowa
The author tries to demonstrate that Georgii Fedotov, who at first sight seems to be not very interested in the philosophy of Marx, was an insightful and very severe critic of marxism. In order to prove it he explains wh...
Czyn czy słowo - co leży u podstaw filozofii pierwszej?
W niniejszym teks cie poro wnuję filozofię bytową, kto rej modelowym przykładem jest filozofia Arystotelesa, z filozofią czynu zaproponowaną przez Stanisława Brzozowskiego. Te dwie konstrukcje ro z nią się co do punktu w...
Mistyka męskości: Franco la Cecli i Roberta Bly'a koncepcja mężczyzny
The object of the paper is to present the two concepts of masculinity worked on the ground of the so-called male studies. The peculiar and distinctive feature of these theories, formulated by Franco La Cecla and Robert B...