Assessing the Effects of Software Platforms on Volumetric Segmentation of Glioblastoma
Journal Title: Journal of Neuroimaging in Psychiatry and Neurology - Year 2016, Vol 1, Issue 2
Abstract
Background: Radiological assessments of biologically relevant regions in glioblastoma have been associated with genotypic characteristics, implying a potential role in personalized medicine. Here, we assess the reproducibility and association with survival of two volumetric segmentation platforms and explore how methodology could impact subsequent interpretation and analysis. Methods: Post-contrast T1- and T2-weighted FLAIR MR images of 67 TCGA patients were segmented into five distinct compartments (necrosis, contrast-enhancement, FLAIR, post contrast abnormal, and total abnormal tumor volumes) by two quantitative image segmentation platforms - 3D Slicer and a method based on Velocity AI and FSL. We investigated the internal consistency of each platform by correlation statistics, association with survival, and concordance with consensus neuroradiologist ratings using ordinal logistic regression. Results: We found high correlations between the two platforms for FLAIR, post contrast abnormal, and total abnormal tumor volumes (spearman’s r(67) = 0.952, 0.959, and 0.969 respectively). Only modest agreement was observed for necrosis and contrast-enhancement volumes (r(67) = 0.693 and 0.773 respectively), likely arising from differences in manual and automated segmentation methods of these regions by 3D Slicer and Velocity AI/FSL, respectively. Survival analysis based on AUC revealed significant predictive power of both platforms for the following volumes: contrast-enhancement, post contrast abnormal, and total abnormal tumor volumes. Finally, ordinal logistic regression demonstrated correspondence to manual ratings for several features. Conclusion: Tumor volume measurements from both volumetric platforms produced highly concordant and reproducible estimates across platforms for general features. As automated or semi-automated volumetric measurements replace manual linear or area measurements, it will become increasingly important to keep in mind that measurement differences between segmentation platforms for more detailed features could influence downstream survival or radio genomic analyses.
Authors and Affiliations
William D. Dunn Jr, Hugo J. W. L. Aerts, Lee A. Cooper, Chad A. Holder, Scott N. Hwang, Carle C. Jaffe, Daniel J. Brat, Rajan Jain, Adam E. Flanders, Pascal O. Zinn, Rivka R. Colen, David A. Gutman
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP223551
- DOI 10.17756/jnpn.2016-008
- Views 134
- Downloads 0
Functional Associations of Temperamental Predisposition and Brain Responses While Processing Stressful Word Stimuli Related to Interpersonal Relationships in Bulimia Nervosa Patients: an fMRI Study
Bulimia nervosa (BN) is characterized by frequent episodes of uncontrolled overeating and difficulties in adapting to stressful situations. BN patients tend to be sensitive to frustration and impulsive. Personality trait...
White Matter Hyperintensities in Older Adults and Motoric Cognitive Risk Syndrome
Introduction: Motoric cognitive risk (MCR) syndrome is a recently described pre-dementia syndrome characterized by slow gait and cognitive complaints that has been implicated as a predictor of cognitive decline and demen...
Alpha Hypersynchrony and Atypical Memory Processes in Soldiers with Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a psychiatric disorder that is associated with a variety of cognitive sequelae, including disorders of memory. We hypothesised that alterations in functional connectivity in PTSD,...
Automated Voxel Placement: A Linux-based Suite of Tools for Accurate and Reliable Single Voxel Coregistration
Background: Single-voxel proton magnetic resonance spectroscopy (¹H MRS) is a powerful technique for studying in vivo neurochemistry, but has an often-overlooked source of error variance: inconsistent voxel placement bet...
Neuroimaging in Psychiatry and Neurology: Current Status and Future Directions
Modern neuroimaging techniques have made a significant contribution to our understanding of human brain and its regulatory mechanisms.