Assessing the Impact of Performance Management Systems on Reward Management and Staff Motivation in Malawi: A Case Study of Lilongwe University of Agriculture and Natural Resources (LUANAR)
Journal Title: Journal of Economics, Finance and Management Studies - Year 2024, Vol 7, Issue 11
Abstract
The study assessed the impact of performance management systems (PMS) on reward management and staff motivation at the Lilongwe University of Agriculture and Natural Resources (LUANAR) in Malawi. Its objectives were: to assess the implementation of the PMS at LUANAR, focusing on its alignment with reward management practices and its effect on staff motivation; to examine the efficacy of the current PMS at LUANAR in enhancing reward management practices and staff motivation; and to identify challenges affecting the optimal functioning of the PMS along with devised interventions at LUANAR. The study utilized Performance Management and Equity Theories to assess PMS alignment with reward practices. A mixed-method design was employed, incorporating qualitative and quantitative approaches. The sample included 106 respondents, comprising: academic staff, administrative personnel, and management officials involved with PMS using purposive sampling for specific groups and simple random sampling for statistical representativeness. Data collection involved semi-structured interviews and structured questionnaires. A 100% questionnaire return rate was achieved. Qualitative data were analyzed thematically to identify patterns, while quantitative data were processed using descriptive statistics with SPSS version 20. The analysis showed that 67% of respondents viewed the alignment between PMS and reward management positively, although 27% noted inconsistencies in reward reflection. Motivation levels varied, with 49% experiencing an increase and 33% reporting a decrease, indicating issues with the clarity of performance-reward links. While 80% of respondents reported a high adoption rate, 10% faced barriers such as insufficient training. Performance metrics were positively rated by 60%, but 15% found them unclear. Additionally, concerns included inconsistent professional development opportunities and perceived inequities in rewards and feedback. Besides, the study noted that the ineffectiveness of the current PMS is due to a lack of coherent government policy and insufficient leadership support, leading to non-adherence to performance practices and a decline in service delivery, which negatively affects staff motivation and rewards. In response, the study recommends that LUANAR refine its PMS by ensuring transparent and consistent reward criteria, improving clarity in performance-reward links, and investing in comprehensive training programs. The university should also clarify performance metrics, standardize feedback protocols, and develop equitable professional development opportunities. Enhancing leadership support for the PMS and addressing perceived inequities in reward distribution are crucial for boosting staff engagement and effectiveness. These recommendations aim at addressing identified deficiencies and improve the implementation and impact of the PMS at LUANAR.
Authors and Affiliations
Daston Raphael Mpando , Ferdinand Chipindi,
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP751982
- DOI 10.47191/jefms/v7-i11-31
- Views 3
- Downloads 0
Enabling Employees to Perform with the Factors that Influence it: The Impact of Democratic Leadership and Work Discipline
Many things must be considered in encouraging the achievement of effective employee performance, knowing these factors will automatically be able to maximize the impact of errors that occur. The role of the leader in env...
The Effect of Workload on Organizational Commitment of Service Section Employees at the Main Branch Office of PT. West Kalimantan Bank: Work-Life Balance (WLB) and Job Satisfaction as Mediation
The aim of this research is to analyze the effect of workload on organizational commitment through work-life balance (WLB) and job satisfaction. The respondents were service section employees at the Main Branch Office of...
Analysis of the Effect of Compensation and Incentives on Employee Job Satisfaction at PT. Longtun Karya Mandiri
This study aims to determine the effect of Compensation and Insentive on employee Job Satisfaction employees at PT. Longtun Karya Mandiri. The data collection method used is the census method using primary data collected...
The Effect of DAR and Firm Size on ROE and Tax Avoidance as ModeratingVariable (Empirical Study on Companies Listed on Idx in the Healthcare Sector -Papan Utama)
This study aims to analyze the effect of DAR, company size on ROE, and Tax Avoidance as a moderator in healthcare companies on the Indonesia Stock Exchange. This study uses secondary data obtained from the website www.ID...
Analysis of Factor Affecting Going Concern Audit Opinion on Manufacturing Companies Sub Sector Food and Beverage Listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange 2015-2019
This research aims to investigate the analysis of variables influencing the audit views on food and beverage manufacturing firms listed on the Indonesia Stock Exchange in 2015-2019. The study is proxied into five variabl...