ASSESSING THE QUALITY OF ELECTRONIC MEDICAL RECORDS IN ACADEMIC HOSPITALS: A MULTICENTER STUDY IN A DEVELOPING COUNTRY
Journal Title: Acta HealthMedica - Year 2017, Vol 2, Issue 1
Abstract
Introduction: The validity of medical research based on electronic databases strongly relies on the quality of recorded data. Although the use of hospital information systems in Iran goes back to 1990s, few studies have assessed the quality of electronic medical records. The aim of this study was to assess the quality of electronic medical records, in the MUMS (Mashhad University of Medical Sciences) hospital information system (HIS), especially valuable ones for education and research. Methods: Samples of inpatient electronic records were selected in three academic hospitals: one general hospital (A) and two tertiary hospitals (B and C). We categorized all data elements of electronic medical records into five groups, including demographic, identification, diagnosis and treatment, administrative and financial; and laboratory and paraclinic. We asked 25 physicians from three academic hospitals to specify data elements with values of medical research and education (called research and educational data) in every group. Next we calculated recordability, completeness, and accuracy of five data groups according to the concordance between electronic records and corresponding paper records. Quality was calculated as a multiple of completeness and accuracy. Results: For all data elements, recordability of the software was 58.5%. Quality of demographic, identification, diagnosis and treatment, laboratory and paraclinic, and administrative and financial data groups was 97%, 32%, 42%, 82%, 89%, respectively, in hospital A. Quality of mentioned data groups was 99%, 44%, 60.5%, 91%, and 95.5% in hospital B, and 98%, 41%, 61%, 30%, and 97% in hospital C, respectively. For data elements, which were selected as valuable for research and education, recordability of the software was 47%. Also, quality of these data categorized in demographic, identification, diagnosis and treatment, laboratory and paraclinic, and administrative and financial was 100%, 67%, 48%, 89%, and 76%, respectively, in hospital A; 100%, 59%, 69%, 95%, and 90% in hospital B; and 100%, 34%, 65%, 32%, and 100% in hospital C, respectively. Conclusion: The low quality of electronic medical records was a result of incompleteness, while accuracy was relatively good. Results showed that the development and use of hospital information system focused on administrative and financial applications more than academic and clinical applications.
Authors and Affiliations
Hedieh Zabolinezhad, Mohammad Reza Hassibian, Shahram Amini, Saeid Eslami
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP351101
- DOI 10.19082/ah127
- Views 122
- Downloads 0
GENETIC EPIDEMIOLOGICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF THE POPULATION OF GHAZAOUET, WILAYA OF TLEMCEN (WEST ALGERIA) BY OBESITY
Background: Obesity is the first non-infectious disease in history. It is a real epidemic that affects both industrialized and developing countries. In Algeria, the problem of obesity is currently a major public health c...
IMPACT OF DATA QUALITY ASSURANCE AND CONTROL SOLUTIONS ON THE COMPLETENESS, ACCURACY, AND CONSISTENCY OF DATA IN A NATIONAL REGISTRY
Introduction: Data quality is of enormous importance in disease registries as the bases for research, evaluation, and policymaking in health systems. The complexity of data quality assurance and control processes in the...
USABILITY EVALUATION OF ADMISSION INFORMATION SYSTEMS IN MASHHAD UNIVERSITY OF MEDICAL SCIENCES HOSPITALS: A HEURISTIC EVALUATION
Introduction: The admission department is one of the most important hospital departments, where patients contact with the hospital at first and begin assessing hospital services. An admission information system is a part...
ESTABLISHMENT OF NATIONAL SPINAL CORD AND COLUMN INJURY REGISTRY OF IRAN (NSCIR-IR): A PROSPECTIVE QUALITY REGISTRY
Introduction: Spinal Cord Injury (SCI), a chronic and disabling condition, is often due to trauma. The annual incidence of SCI in the Iranian male and female population is an estimated 98.4 and 46.5 in 100,000, respectiv...
GENETIC EPIDEMIOLOGICAL CHARACTERIZATION OF THE POPULATION OF TLEMCEN (WEST ALGERIA) BY TYPE 1 DIABETES
Background: Type 1 diabetes is a real public health problem, concerning not only its complications and cost, but also its increasing incidence and the fact that it occurs in young people. The objective of this study is t...