Can analytical shading be art? Reflections on the canvas of experiments with ArcGIS and Surfer
Journal Title: Polish Cartographical Review - Year 2015, Vol 47, Issue 3
Abstract
Despite numerous theoretical and experimental studies of analytical relief shading, devised about half a century ago, its quality has not yet reached the excellence of traditional (manual) shading. The paper discusses its basic principles and the main factors affecting the quality of shading. It also stresses the crucial importance of the digital terrain model used as the basis for shading as well as the proper generalization of the relief. Experiments with shading modules of ArcGIS and Surfer, aiming to explore the functionality of algorithms they employ, have demonstrated significant similarity of the results. In conclusion, the authors attempt to answer the question posted in the title of the article. In their view, analytical shading is not art because shading algorithms are incapable of producing the visually beautiful effects that an experienced cartographer with artistic talents can create.
Authors and Affiliations
JERZY SIWEK SIWEK, WOJCIECH WACŁAWIK WACŁAWIK
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP366934
- DOI 10.1515/pcr-2015-0010
- Views 84
- Downloads 0
Visual features of cartographic representation in map perception
The author describes the properties and mechanisms of visual perception in the context of their significance to the principles of symbol design as used in cartography. Map perception relies on the process of visual perce...
Symbol changes on 20th century topographic maps in 1:100 000
The 20th century was a time of change in the concept of topographic map design. The article focuses on analysis related to the influence of 20th century technological changes in the graphic form of symbols applied on top...
Effectiveness of cartographic presentation in the new generation of topographic maps
One of the key challenges in the process of development of IIP (Infrastructure for Spatial Information) in Poland is the construction of a complex model of a multi-resolution database of topographic objects. Effective i...
An attempt of comparison of the content of woodcut and copperplate maps issued in Europe until the beginning of the 19th century Próba porównania zawartości map drzeworytowych i miedziorytowych publikowanych w Europie do początku XIX wieku
The analysis of the content of maps showed to what extent the quality of the 15th and 16th century maps was the result of the available copying techniques and to what extent the possibilities provided by the woodcut and...
Elaboration of topographic bases for statistical maps, their contents and importance
The author’s objective is to present the role of base contents for a statistical map and determine its desired features which would influence optimum perception of the main contents of the map. The article consists of tw...