Can the Chinese Robot Think?
Journal Title: Philosophy and Cosmology - Year 2017, Vol 19, Issue
Abstract
In the paper, I discuss the Chinese room thought experiment, which was proposed by John Searle to show that executing by a computer of a program of data processing is not enough for genuine, i.e. understanding-based, thinking. The objection — advanced by Vadim Vasilyev — is also discussed that if the Chinese room is supplemented with devices to obtain external data, and so transformed into the Chinese robot, it may be attributed an understanding mind. Arguments are proposed that supplement those of Searle and give reason to turn down the objection. First, it is pointed out that the suggestion that the Chinese robot will have a specifi c program that has a quasi-semantic character and describes the relationship between linguistic signs and physical data is mistaken, because all the relations that programs assign are relations between units of inherently meaningless “data” — series of bits that have no inherent meaning but acquire their meaning only owing to conscious (human) interpreters. Second, it is argued that the robot’s acquiring “knowledge” (data, as states of its memory cells) in the process of its interaction with the external world makes no relevant diff erence, because any such data can be just as well written in the same robot’s memory cells from the very beginning
Authors and Affiliations
Dmytro Sepetyi
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP244688
- DOI -
- Views 71
- Downloads 0
The Biosphere as a Living System. On Peculiarities of the Evolutionary Process on the Biosphere Level
The main purpose of this second essay the “biospherology” is to streamline and formalize the existing knowledge about the biosphere, to develop the theoretical basis of the theory of evolution of the biosphere. Despite t...
The Role of Trade Unions in the Development of the Aerospace Industry
The development of society in the direction of space exploration makes its own adjustments to the development of trade unions. A new system of social partnership is being created in society, in which individualized forms...
Zonal-and-Wave Structure of Open Systems on Micro, Mega- and Macrolevels of the Universe
The analysis of formation of wave astrodynamics as the applied science that studying zonal-andwave structure of megasystems in the Universe is executed. The perspective of disclosure of physical essence of the phenomenon...
World Spirit” by George Hegel: from Universe to the History of Mankind
The article analyzes the universal methodological potential of the philosophical theory of Georg Hegel in interpretation and forecasting of the universe from the study of rationally justified models of the Universe (alon...
Making Sense of the Mental Universe
In 2005, an essay was published in Nature asserting that the universe is mental and that we must abandon our tendency to conceptualize observations as things. Since then, experiments have confi rmed that — as predicted b...