Cauchy, infinitesimals and ghosts of departed quantifiers
Journal Title: Математичні Студії - Year 2017, Vol 47, Issue 2
Abstract
rocedures relying on infinitesimals in Leibniz, Euler and Cauchy have been interpreted in both a Weierstrassian and Robinson’s frameworks. The latter provides closer proxies for the procedures of the classical masters. Thus, Leibniz’s distinction between assignable and inassignable numbers finds a proxy in the distinction between standard and nonstandard numbers in Robinson’s framework, while Leibniz’s law of homogeneity with the implied notion of equality up to negligible terms finds a mathematical formalisation in terms of standard part. It is hard to provide parallel formalisations in a Weierstrassian framework but scholars since Ishiguro have engaged in a quest for ghosts of departed quantifiers to provide a Weierstrassian account for Leibniz’s infinitesimals. Euler similarly had notions of equality up to negligible terms, of which he distinguished two types: geometric and arithmetic. Euler routinely used product decompositions into a specific infinite number of factors, and used the binomial formula with an infinite exponent. Such procedures have immediate hyperfinite analogues in Robinson’s framework, while in a Weierstrassian framework they can only be reinterpreted by means of paraphrases departing significantly from Euler’s own presentation. Cauchy gives lucid definitions of continuity in terms of infinitesimals that find ready formalisations in Robinson’s framework but scholars working in a Weierstrassian framework bend over backwards either to claim that Cauchy was vague or to engage in a quest for ghosts of departed quantifiers in his work. Cauchy’s procedures in the context of his 1853 sum theorem (for series of continuous functions) are more readily understood from the viewpoint of Robinson’s framework, where one can exploit tools such as the pointwise definition of the concept of uniform convergence. As case studies, we analyze the approaches of Craig Fraser and Jesper LЁutzen to Cauchy’s contributions to infinitesimal analysis, as well as Fraser’s approach toward Leibniz’s theoretical strategy in dealing with infinitesimals. The insights by philosophers Ian Hacking and others into the important roles of contextuality and contingency tend to undermine Fraser’s interpretive framework.
Authors and Affiliations
J. Bair, P. Blaszczyk, R. Ely, V. Henry, K. U. Katz, M. G. Katz, Taras Kudryk, S. S. Kutateladze, T. McGaffey, D. M. Schaps, D. Sherry
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP310088
- DOI 10.15330/ms.47.2.115-144
- Views 47
- Downloads 0
Automorphism groups of superextensions of groups
A family L of subsets of a set X is called {\em linked} if A∩B≠∅ for all A,B∈L. A linked family M is {\em maximal linked} if M coincides with each linked family L on X that contains M. The superextension λ(X) consists of...
The Fourier problem for weakly nonlinear integro-differential elliptic-parabolic systems
The Fourier problem or, in other words, the problem without initial conditions for weakly nonlinear elliptic-parabolic systems are considered in this paper. The existence and uniqueness solutions of the problem are prove...
Progress in the open problems in theory of functions of bounded index
We give overview of solved problems in theory of functions of bounded index from the paper Bandura, A.I., Skaskiv, O.B.: Open problems for entire functions of bounded index in direction. Mat. Stud. 43(1), 103–109 (2015)....
The algebra of symmetric polynomials on (L∞)n
The paper deals with continuous symmetric (invariant under composition of the variable with any measure preserving bijection of [0,1]) complex-valued polynomials on the nth Cartesian power of the complex Banach space L∞...
Nonlocal multipoint problem for an ordinary differential equations of even order involution
We study a nonlocal multipoint problem for an ordinary differential equation of even order with coefficients containing an involution operator. The spectral properties of a self-adjoint operator with boundary conditions...