Comparative Analysis of 1D and 2D Modeling Approaches for Scour Depth Estimation: A Case Study of the Kelanisiri Bridge, Sri Lanka
Journal Title: Journal of Civil and Hydraulic Engineering - Year 2024, Vol 2, Issue 3
Abstract
The scouring process, characterised by the erosion of sediment around bridge piers due to fluid flow, poses a significant risk to the structural integrity of bridges. Scour depth, defined as the vertical distance from the initial riverbed level to the bottom of the scour hole, is driven by the formation of vortices near bridge piers. Mitigating scour damage after it has advanced to a critical stage is often more disruptive and costly than preemptive measures based on accurate predictions. In response to this challenge, a range of one-dimensional (1D) and two-dimensional (2D) numerical modelling techniques has been developed for scour depth estimation around bridge piers. Among the available methods, the Hydrologic Engineering Center's River Analysis System (HEC-RAS) is widely employed, with the majority of studies focusing on the 1D modelling approach. The current study evaluates the relative efficacy of 1D and 2D models using the case of the Kelanisiri Bridge, which traverses the Kelani River in Sri Lanka. The performance of the 1D model was assessed by comparing predicted water levels at an intermediate river gauge with field data, while the 2D model was calibrated and validated against observed riverbed levels. Both approaches were applied to estimate scour depths following the 2016 flood event. The findings revealed that the 2D HEC-RAS model provided a superior match with observed field data when compared to the 1D model, achieving a coefficient of determination (R2) of 0.98 and a root mean square error (RMSE) of 0.13, indicating a higher degree of accuracy and reliability. As a result, the 2D model is recommended as the more effective approach for predicting scour depth around bridge piers. Further validation of these numerical results through scaled laboratory physical modelling is recommended to ensure greater accuracy in future predictive efforts.
Authors and Affiliations
Ashvinie Thembiliyagoda, Kasun De Silva, Nimal Wijayaratna
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP746408
- DOI https://doi.org/10.56578/jche020304
- Views 37
- Downloads 0
Mechanisms of Cracking and Stress Control During the Construction Phase of Concrete Face Rockfill Dams in Cold Regions
The construction phase of concrete face rockfill dams is often marred by prominent panel cracking issues, with a lack of reliable foundations for anti-cracking design. To control tensile stresses and enhance crack resist...
Stability Analysis of Steel Columns with Fixed-Free Ends under Axial Compression: Uniform and Non-Uniform Square Hollow Sections
This study investigates the stability of steel columns subjected to axial compression, focusing on square hollow sections (SHS) with both uniform and non-uniform cross-sections. The stability of fixed-free end SHS column...
Numerical Simulation of Resistivity Response Characteristics in Seepage Detection of Cutoff Walls Using Cross-Hole Resistivity Tomography
Cutoff walls are an essential method for seepage prevention in dams. During the construction and operation of reservoirs, factors such as construction techniques, variations in groundwater conditions within the dam body,...
Research and Experimentation on the Orthogonal Error Correction Method for Horizontal Displacement Monitoring
Dam deformation monitoring is a critical technical measure to ensure the safe and stable operation of dams. It involves measuring the structural deformation response of engineering dams using monitoring instruments or te...
Investigating the Properties and Determinants of Underwater Anti-Dispersive Cementitious Soil with Kaolin: An Experimental Approach
Pile foundations, as one of the main foundation forms for bridges and offshore wind power structures, are prone to scour pits around them under the long-term action of water flow, leading to a decrease in bearing capacit...