Comparative Analysis of In-service and Pre-service Teachers’ Critical Thinking Skills; A Thematic Approach Based on the California Critical Thinking Disposition Inventory
Journal Title: Journal of Education, Society and Behavioural Science - Year 2017, Vol 23, Issue 4
Abstract
Aims: This paper compares the critical thinking abilities and dispositions of pre-service and in-service teachers to delineate factors that account for their difference. The tertiary pre-service programme is a major source of teachers for the schools in Botswana and as such there is a need for a deliberate alignment of teacher development programme objectives and classroom practice in the field. One area of concern is the difference in the critical thinking skills between tertiary students and practicing teachers. The apparent difference in the conceptualization of critical thinking as a construct between pre-service and in-service teachers is an indication of a possible misfit between conditions within schools and what pre-service teachers expect to find in the classroom when they start teaching. This has implications for in-service and pre-service teacher development, subject-matter organization and general classroom processes. Methodology: A qualitative multiple case study approach was used to collect and analyze textual data from pre-service and in-serve teachers in Botswana. Participants from the two subgroups responded to a critical thinking instrument designed to capture their opinion regarding different aspects of the critical thinking construct. The data was analyzed using thematic mapping based on the subcategories of the California Critical Thinking Disposition Inventory Results: The results showed that pre-service teachers were mostly preoccupied with the analyticity aspect of critical thinking while their in-service counterparts exhibited a much broader understanding of the construct. However, the two groups expressed similar ideas in matters relating to factors that impede successful development of critical thinking skills and dispositions.
Authors and Affiliations
Molefhe Mogapi, Waitshega Tefo Smitta Moalosi
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP320996
- DOI 10.9734/JESBS/2017/38979
- Views 139
- Downloads 0
New Proposals for Early Development in Mexico According to Cultural Neuropsychology
According to conception of historical and cultural psychology, introduced by L.S. Vigotsky, early childhood should be understood as a specific period of development or specific psychological age. Appropriate ways of care...
Reducing Prejudice through Multicultural Education in Albania
In Albania, the Roma people face very difficult living conditions and frequent discrimination situations especially as related to their access to schools. The legal framework in effect guarantees the right to education r...
Effective Teaching and Learning Strategies in Science and Mathematics to Improve Students’ Academic Performance in Nigeria
The paper focused on the effective use of science and mathematics teaching and learning strategies for the improving students’ academic performance. It highlighted on the concept of teaching and learning strategies, teac...
Impact of Child Labour on Human Capital Development in Onitsha, Anambra State, Nigeria
In a bid to survive the hard times in the economy, some families have resorted to giving out their children as child labourers so as to earn income for subsistence. This phenomenon has scuttled efforts aimed at human cap...
Implications of Hawking Activities on the Kumasi Campus of University of Education, Winneba
Street vending or hawking has become an important economic activity highly patronized by persons with limited educational and professional training especially in developing countries. It is characterized by traders trans...