Comparison of the effectiveness of selected medical segregation systems - START, SIEVE, CAREFLIGHT.
Journal Title: Critical Care Innovations - Year 2019, Vol 2, Issue 1
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: In the face of sudden events with many victims, various types of medical segregation systems were created. Their aim is to set the treatment and transport priority of patients by giving them appropriate urgency codes considering their general condition and vital parameters. The study is aimed at comparing the effectiveness of selected medical segregation systems. MATERIAL AND METHODS: The research tool consisted of one hundred virtual patients, whose condition was categorized according to the START system (Simple Triage and Rapid Treatment) for four urgency codes - 25 persons for each of four categories. Then they were segregated by assigning the wounded to individual urgency codes using the SIEVE and CAREFLIGHT systems. To the statistical analysis was used the Mann-Whitney U test. All results were considered significant at p <0.05. RESULTS: Among 100 patients using the SIEVE system, 25 were identified in green and black code, 27 in yellow code and 23 in red code. Using the CAREFLIGHT system, 25 patients were shown in green and black code, 31 in yellow code and 19 in red code. There were no differences between segregation systems between green and black code patients (Code 3 and 4: START = 25 vs. SIEVE = 25 vs. CAREFLIGHT = 25). In contrast, the yellow code showed differences in the SIEVE system compared to the control group - START system (p = 0.005, Code 2: START = 25 vs. SIEVE = 18), which, however, was not demonstrated in relation to CAREFLIGHT (Code 2: START = 25 vs. CAREFLIGHT = 25). In the red code showed differences between the control group and the SIEVE system (p = 0.001, Code 1: START = 25 vs SIEVE = 16), and the CAREFLIGHT system (p = 0.010, Code 1: START = 25 vs. CAREFLIGHT = 19). CONCLUSIONS: The effectiveness of selected medical segregation systems (START, SIEVE and CAREFLIGHT) is significantly different among patients in yellow and red code. Taking into account the highest urgency code, the most sensitive selection is shown by the START system, and the least sensitive - CAREFLIGHT.
Authors and Affiliations
Monika Klepacka, Paweł Bakalarski, Pamela Antonella Gajek Villebæk, Piotr Konrad Leszczyński
Patient in hypothermia - diagnostic and treatment problems in fire department
Accidental hypothermia occurs when, as a result of environmental factors, the central body temperature drops below 35° C. Deep hypothermia is a life-threatening condition, but it is one of the reversible causes of cardia...
Comparison of resuscitation techniques using pocket-mask in tactical medicine.
INTRODUCTION: The technique of resuscitating or supporting inefficient breathing on the battlefield can be carried out using the soldier's mask. However, carrying out this activity by one rescuer requires the use of the...
Survival in sudden cardiac arrest in emergency room: case-control study.
INTRODUCTION: Systematic analysis of risk factors, causes of sudden death and patient survivability allows implementation of increasingly effective methods and procedures for emergency cardiac arrest (SCA). The condition...
Knowledge of the in-hospital resuscitation algorithm among medical staff of selected hospital departments.
INTRODUCTION: The hospitalized patient has a potentially greater chance of surviving sudden cardiac arrest compared to pre-hospital conditions. This, however, requires proper preparation of medical personnel who should r...
Characteristics of ambulance intervention for female patients in perinatal period.
INTRODUCTION: In pre-hospital conditions, the diagnosis of patients in the perinatal period is very limited. Emergency ambulance calls to pregnant women should only apply to emergency situations related to the risk of ma...