Comparison of Two Survey Methods Based on Response Distribution of Pediatricians Regarding Immunization for Children in India: Mail versus Telephone
Journal Title: International Journal of TROPICAL DISEASE & Health - Year 2016, Vol 16, Issue 2
Abstract
Introduction: The use of telephone and mail surveys raises the question to what extent the results of different data collection methods deviate from one another. Aim: To determine if there is any difference in the response distribution between telephone and mail surveys of vaccination related-attitudes. Methods: A random sample of 400 pediatricians who are members of the India Academy of Pediatrics and work at various locations in India was selected. Mantel-Haenszel chi-square test was applied; significance level was alpha=0.05. Difference in percentage points of the majority response was calculated in the following way ∆=telephone% - mail%. Results: Only 36% responded to mail surveys and 57% responded to telephone surveys. Pediatricians in both telephone and mail surveys agreed for the majority of survey questions but to a different degree on particular items. More pediatricians in the telephone arm responded that measles eradication is important with a p=0.001 and ∆=8.3. More mail than telephone respondents reported that it is parents’ responsibility to ensure child is vaccinated (∆= -7.9, P=0.002) and that they would refer parents to a facility of their choice to get vaccines (∆=14, P=0.008). Conclusion: The results show evidence of the interviewer and/or social desirability bias and its influence on response choices. This suggests that mode of administration should be standardized or carefully adjusted for during analysis. Alternatively, further question development may minimize the sensitivity of items to mode of data collection.
Authors and Affiliations
Roy L. Zhang, Naveen Thacker, Panna Choudhury, Karen Pazol, Walter A. Orenstein, Saad B. Omer, James M. Hughes, Paul S. Weiss, Lisa M. Gargano
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP329081
- DOI 10.9734/IJTDH/2016/24051
- Views 56
- Downloads 0
Prevalence of Pulmonary Mycoses among HIV Infected Clients Attending Anti-Retroviral Therapy Clinic at Kisoro District Hospital, Western Uganda
Aim: For determining the prevalence of pulmonary mycosis among HIV infected clients attending anti-retroviral therapy clinic at Kisoro district Hospital in Western Uganda. Study Design: This was a cross- sectional study....
Challenges of Malaria Diagnosis in Paediatric Patients at a Nigerian Hospital
Aims: This study compares the performance of routine malaria diagnostic tests, and explores the challenges of malaria diagnosis in paediatric patients in an endemic setting in South West Nigeria. Study Design: Cross sec...
Weight Loss and Nutritional Status of 6-59 Months Children after Positive Deviance/Hearth Approach in Southern Benin Rural Area: Associated Factors to Later Underweight
Aims: To appreciate the evolution of weight gain by malnourished children and factors associated to children underweight after the Positive Deviance/Hearth sessions. Study Design: Longitudinal study. Place and Duration...
Trend in Malaria Incidence Rates (2006-2013) in Edo State, Nigeria
Background: Detailed information on the severity of malaria and other diseases across operational areas is a prerequisite to the judicious utilization of limited effective tools for the control in Africa. Methods: Record...
An Analysis of Seasonal Variation and Climatic Influences on the Male to Female Ratio of Live Births in Malta
Aims: In humans, male births occur in excess of female births. The ratio of male births to total births (MFR) is expected to approximate 0.515. Many factors have been shown to influence MRF and a seasonal pattern has als...