Conciliar Christology and the Problem of Incompatible Predications
Journal Title: Scientia et Fides - Year 2015, Vol 3, Issue 2
Abstract
In this article I canvas the options available to a proponent of the traditional doctrine of the incarnation against a charge of incoherence. In particular, I consider the charge of incoherence due to incompatible predications both being true of the same one person, the God-man Jesus Christ. For instance, one might think that anything divine has to have certain attributes – perhaps omnipotence, or impassibility. But, the charge continues, nothing human can be omnipotent or impassible. And so nothing can be divine and human. So Christ is not both God and man, contrary to the traditional doctrine of the incarnation. To do so, first, in Section II, I will present the problem as a deductively valid argument. I then, in that section, go on to show that the proponent of traditional Christology should grant all but one premise of the argument. In the remaining sections I will canvas possible solutions to the problem. In Section III I discuss three ways to deny Premise 3 of the forthcoming argument. These ways include a Kenotic response, qua-modification (in four versions), and finally a response that accepts the compatibility of the allegedly incompatible predicates.
Authors and Affiliations
Timothy Pawl
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP194969
- DOI 10.12775/SetF.2015.019
- Views 98
- Downloads 0
La evolución, entre ciencia, razón y fe
Evolution: Between Science, Reason, and Faith Evolution is a topic of interest to science, philosophy and Christian theology. We look for the points of dialogue. We will follow this outline: 1. An introduction where we...
El olvido de los presupuestos de la ciencia y de la filosofía
The neglect of the presuppositions of science and philosophy This paper is based on the suggestion of Professor Artigas in order to bring to light the epistemological and ontological assumptions of scientific activity,...
El argumento de diseño y la quinta vía de Santo Tomás
The argument from design and Aquinas’ fifth way In scientific literature it is common to make equivalence between the so-called argument from design and the fifth way of Thomas Aquinas. It is commonly assumed that both...
Emergence and Downward Causation Reconsidered in Terms of the Aristotelian-Thomistic View of Causation and Divine Action
One of the main challenges of the nonreductionist approach to complex structures and phenomena in philosophy of biology is its defense of the plausibility of the theory of emergence and downward causation. The tension be...
Historiosophy of August Cieszkowski in the context of contemporary consciousness
Cieszkowski’s philosophy embodies the most influential trends in philosophy and culture of the nineteenth century. This does not mean, however, that Cieszkowski’s philosophy has today only historical character and it is...