Cosmopolitan Emancipation of Judges
Journal Title: Krytyka Prawa. Niezależne studia nad prawem - Year 2014, Vol 6, Issue 1
Abstract
This article seeks to identify characteristic features of judicial cosmopolitanism and its product - the emancipation of judges from the constraints of national law. Cosmopolitanism manifests itself in creating normative systems outside and above traditional international law. While the latter draws its binding power from the will of states, cosmopolitan rules are usually created by private actors. Their binding power results predominantly from practical necessity. Such is the status of lex sportiva, of the standards imposed by rating agencies, or of international accreditation bodies. Judicial cosmopolitanism is different, for it rests upon the existing structures and competencies. By resorting to alien legal sources judges free themselves from national constraints, thus enhancing their power and independence. In assessing the impact of cosmopolitanism, one has to differentiate between looking up to foreign laws and precedents as binding sources, and treating them as merely intellectual inspiration. The first approach is extremely rare, and constitutionally prohibited in most jurisdictions. The second, albeit it seems innocuous, entails serious perils to the quality of adjudication. It creates a danger of cherry-picking by selecting foreign inspirations, not necessarily best suited to the case at hand. More often than not, invoking foreign sources is superficial, conducted without even rudimentary knowledge of their systemic background. Also, there is a danger of judicial overstepping of powers by making laws instead of merely applying it. By allowing judges to venture the uncontrolled expansion of their powers we endanger the very essence of the rule of law. On a positive note, drawing on foreign legal sources enables judges to verify the rationality of their decisions, as they were already tested in other jurisdictions.
Authors and Affiliations
Waldemar Hoff
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP62468
- DOI -
- Views 78
- Downloads 0
On The Comprehensive Regulation of the Sphere of Public Documents in Poland
This paper offers an analysis of a draft bill on Public Documents together with implementing acts. It focuses, in particular, on the key regulations concerning the list of public documents and their classification, on th...
The Era of Reproductive Genetics on Aldous Huxley’s Self-Fulfilling Prophesies
The paper presents the world of literary vision of “the power of medicine” sketched by Aldous Huxley in his book Brave New World. Huxley created a futuristic image of society which reaches a state of complete organizatio...
W poszukiwaniu presupozycji ontologicznych krytycznej nauki o prawie
Celem niniejszego artykułu jest podjęcie refleksji nad presupozycjami ontologicznymi krytycznej nauki o prawie (prawoznawstwa krytycznego), rozumianymi jako zbiór założeń z zakresu ontologii społecznej, wyznaczających to...
[b][i]Legal Principle of Equality in International Law[/i][/b]
Implementation of Private Law Institutions into Public Law on the Example of Mediation in the Code of Administrative Procedure – Remedy or Placebo?
This article is an attempt to critically evaluate the implementation of the Polish Code of Conduct for the Administration of Mediation Institutions. The author considers the legitimacy of the use of private-law instituti...