Criminal liability and the tort liability under administrative law
Journal Title: Наукові записки НаУКМА. Юридичні науки - Year 2018, Vol 0, Issue
Abstract
The article provides critical analysis of contemporary Ukrainian approaches to defining “criminal liability” and “tort liability under administrative law” as well as the approaches to defining the difference between the two liability types. The author’s idea is that the latter term should not be substituted by administrative liability in its “managerial” sense, being a liability of renewable type. The tort liability under administrative law does not belong to purely administrative type in managerial sense. It has penal features thus coming closely to criminal liability. These penal features create the essence of criminal liability. Nevertheless, the inclusion of the article on legal liability in the statute with a certain name (e.g. The Code of Ukraine on Administrative Offences), its procedural form and the name of the offence triggering the liability do not necessarily correspond with the essence of legal liability. The article also stipulates the conclusion that the essential equality of criminal offences and administrative offences, as well as of the criminal liability and tort liability under administrative law, and the wide acceptance of this approach within national legal system will provide a positive effect, specifically in: 1) further development of Criminal law and the Tort Administrative Law as a united legal area triggering its systematization, unification, elimination of legal gaps, conflict of norms, unreasonable competition between the norms etc.; 2) further exercise of legal certainty principle together with other components of the rule of law; 3) the appropriate securing of the rights of aggrieved persons as well as of the rights of offenders according to the criminal procedure standards; 4) logical and full classification of criminal offences and just differentiation of liability; 5) possibility to build up the procedural form considering the well classified system of criminal offences; 6) valid designation of the range of criminal offences triggering administrative liability with the possibility to challenge the issue in the court.
Authors and Affiliations
Denys Azarov
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP486214
- DOI 10.18523/2617-2607.2018.99-109
- Views 47
- Downloads 0
Scientific horizons of administrative law: tendencies and perspectives
Some features of the development of the science of administrative law have been researched in the article since the adoption of the Concept of Administrative Reform to date. The author addressed the study to analyze the...
IMPLEMENTATION OF SPIRIT OF LAW MECHANISM IN NEW PROCESSUAL CODES
This scientific article is dedicated to finding out whether the task of the justice could be considered as a component of the “spirit” of law and whether the novel of procedural codes is possible to be considered as a me...
SCHOOL OF LEGAL REALISM: SEARCH OF BALANCE BETWEEN THE CERTAINTY OF LEGAL RULES AND JUDICIAL DISCRETION
The article addresses the conceptual foundations of the establishers of legal realism in determining the role of the judge’s personality in turning verdict and building legal argumentation. While being in search for inst...
Представництво в цивільному процесі за новим Цивільним процесуальним кодексом України
У статті здійснено аналіз норми нової редакції Цивільного процесуального кодексу України щодо процесуального представництва, порівняння положень щодо процесуального представництва в різних видах судочинства, зокрема з го...
Pre-Extraditionary Supervisory Probation as the Newest Rule of Law Observance Mechanism while Deciding on the Issuing a Person (Extradition)
Modernization of the norms of criminal and procedural law is extremely important for the smooth functions of all state authorities, ensuring an adequate level of legal protection of the society and prospects of internati...