Críticas ao "Tree Thinking": elucidando o significado das relações filogenéticas
Journal Title: Pesquisa e Ensino em Ciências Exatas e da Natureza - Year 2017, Vol 1, Issue 2
Abstract
The "Tree Thinking" is regarded as the dominant methodology in current Systematic Biology. However, criticisms of the procedures carried out by it are diverse. Here the criticisms made by Fitzhugh regarding its philosophical basis and the consequences of such modifications are presented and defended. Thus, the present work aims to demonstrate that ‚Tree Thinking‛, as it has been used, is incomplete because it does not recognize that phylogenetic relationships are of the causal type previously summarized in an explanatory sketch (cladogram). In addition, to support such an argument, a discussion on the definition and objectives of Systematic Biology and ‚Tree Thinking‛ is provided. As a result, it is possible to observe confusion between classifying and systematizing the knowledge by those who follow "Tree Thinking". In addition, ‚Tree Thinking‛ fails to provide causal explanations regarding the origin and fixation of the characteristics studied. In this way, ‚Tree Thinking‛ can be considered an incomplete practice within Systematic Biology and, therefore, the application of the proposals of Fitzhugh are recommended.
Authors and Affiliations
Rafael Souza
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP253939
- DOI -
- Views 125
- Downloads 0
NEW RECORDS OF TWO SPECIES OF ACANTHOCARPUS STIMPSON, 1871 (CRUSTACEA: DECAPODA: CALAPPIDAE) IN NORTHEASTERN BRAZIL
The gladiator box crab of the genus Acanthocarpus Stimpson, 1871 has benthonic habits, occurring in continental shelf on gravel or muddy substrates with occurrence in all oceans, especially between 20-522 m depth. In thi...
Análise do conteúdo de Evolução em livros didáticos do Ensino Fundamental brasileiro
The Theory of Evolution is not only the unifying force in Biology, but also one of the most important scientific concepts ever developed. However, the topic has always been neglected or misrepresented, resulting in a pop...
PAPEL DAS MOSCAS (INSECTA, DIPTERA) NA ENTOMOLOGIA FORENSE
This paper presents a brief review of the role of flies (Insecta, Diptera) in Forensic Entomology. Discussions on presence in human cadavers and vertebrate carcasses, Postmortem Interval (PMI) estimations, studies carrie...
Críticas ao "Tree Thinking": elucidando o significado das relações filogenéticas
The "Tree Thinking" is regarded as the dominant methodology in current Systematic Biology. However, criticisms of the procedures carried out by it are diverse. Here the criticisms made by Fitzhugh regarding its philosoph...
Physical, biological and human-induced effects on the reef fishes of Fernando de Noronha archipelago, Brazil
Several factors have the potential to influence the distribution and composition of reef fish communities. Amongst the most important are rugosity, wave exposure, substrate cover and human activities. The present study e...