Críticas ao "Tree Thinking": elucidando o significado das relações filogenéticas
Journal Title: Pesquisa e Ensino em Ciências Exatas e da Natureza - Year 2017, Vol 1, Issue 2
Abstract
The "Tree Thinking" is regarded as the dominant methodology in current Systematic Biology. However, criticisms of the procedures carried out by it are diverse. Here the criticisms made by Fitzhugh regarding its philosophical basis and the consequences of such modifications are presented and defended. Thus, the present work aims to demonstrate that ‚Tree Thinking‛, as it has been used, is incomplete because it does not recognize that phylogenetic relationships are of the causal type previously summarized in an explanatory sketch (cladogram). In addition, to support such an argument, a discussion on the definition and objectives of Systematic Biology and ‚Tree Thinking‛ is provided. As a result, it is possible to observe confusion between classifying and systematizing the knowledge by those who follow "Tree Thinking". In addition, ‚Tree Thinking‛ fails to provide causal explanations regarding the origin and fixation of the characteristics studied. In this way, ‚Tree Thinking‛ can be considered an incomplete practice within Systematic Biology and, therefore, the application of the proposals of Fitzhugh are recommended.
Authors and Affiliations
Rafael Souza
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP253939
- DOI -
- Views 132
- Downloads 0
Acidentes causados por aranhas e escorpiões no Estado do Ceará, Nordeste do Brasil: casos subnotificados e superestimados baseados na distribuição geográfica das espécies
The accidents caused by arachnids have increased its frequency along the years and the majority of accidents reports do not contain species identification, contributing to underreporting of data. In Ceará state, specific...
Predation of Dermatonotus muelleri (Anura, Microhylidae) by Guira guira (Cuculiformes, Cuculidae) in the coastline of the Sergipe state, northeastern Brazil
Predation can drive significant effect upon the community structure. However, the observation and documentation of this ecological interaction is occasional and yet scarce for many groups. Our goal here is to report the...
Aranhas epígeas de um fragmento de mata em área urbana em Fortaleza, Ceará, Brasil
Spiders are indicators of environment quality due fact of been sensible to environment changes. Their adaptions among the environment and their relations between vegetal communities make them have a special role in fores...
Bats (Mammalia, Chiroptera) from an area of Caatinga in southwestern Bahia, Brazil
The present study provides an inventory of the bat species recorded in the municipality of Caetité, in southwestern Bahia, Brazil. Sixty-eight individuals were captured, belonging to nine species and three families. The...
Checklist of the Holothuroidea (Echinodermata) from the State of Paraíba, Brazil
The study presents the first species list for holothurians from the coast of the State of Paraíba, northeastern Brazil. The list was made based on the study of specimens deposited in the Invertebrate Collection Paulo You...