Discourses on Religious Violence in Premodern Japan
Journal Title: Religions - Year 2018, Vol 9, Issue 5
Abstract
This article asks what religious violence is and why it is relevant. It questions common assumptions by focusing on how monastic violence unfolded in premodern Japan. It argues that there was nothing that set this particular form of violence apart in terms of what the clerics fought for, their ideological justification, who fought, or how they fought. Although myths prevail on the largely fictive figure of the sohei ¯ , or “monk-warriors,” closer scrutiny indicates that their depiction first emerged as a coherent literary concept in the early Tokugawa period. Regarding the ideological framework in which incidents of so-called monastic violence took place, the paper demonstrates that the individuals involved in such conflicts—including the clerics—cannot be dissociated from their own socio-historical context. This is because the medieval Japanese setting was based on rules of cooperation that also implied competition among various elites. The paper further complicates our understanding by showing that the central issue is not why specific violent events involving clerics occurred, but rather what constituted the mental framework—or mentalité—of the age, and how it allowed religious institutions to play such a prominent role.
Authors and Affiliations
Mikael Adolphson
Between Socialism and Feminism: Charlotte Glas (1873–1944)
This article explores how Charlotte Glas, a founding member of the Austrian Social Democratic Party and a leading figure in the public sphere during the late imperial period, attempted to advance the cause of workers’...
Agitators, Tranquilizers, or Something Else: Do Religious Groups Increase or Decrease Contentious Collective Action?
This article critically assesses existing scholarship on the roles that religious groups play in collective contention. Researchers disagree on three main issues: (a) whether religious doctrines and values make religio...
The Cross-Cultural Kingship in Early Medieval Kamar ¯ upa: Blood, Desire and Magic
Kingship in early medieval Kamar ¯ upa (Assam) was influenced by the collision of orthodox ¯ and heterodox Brahmanic traditions with various tribal cultures. Since the last part of the S´alastambha ¯ period (seventh–te...
Eastern Orthodox Christianity and the Uses of the Past in Contemporary Greece
The article examines the use of Orthodox Christianity in the debates over the cultural heritage of contemporary Greece. Since the birth of modern Greece, Orthodox Christianity has been used as one of the foundational c...
The Green Revolution in the World’s Religions: Indonesian Examples in International Comparison
Similar to progressive political movements, the programs of many religious and spiritual groups today are converging around a shared commitment to address the impending global ecological crisis. The paper explores this...