Disintegrating Particles, Non-Local Causation and Category Mistakes: What do Conservation Laws have to do with Dualism?
Journal Title: Conatus - Journal of Philosophy - Year 2017, Vol 2, Issue 2
Abstract
The single most influential and widely accepted objection against any form of dualism, the belief that human beings are both body and soul, is the objection that dualism violates conservation laws in physics. The conservation laws objection against dualism posits that body and soul interaction is at best mysterious, and at worst impossible. While this objection has been both influential from the time of its initial formulation until present, this paper occupies itself with arguing that this objection is a fleeting one, and has successful answers from both scientific and philosophical perspectives. It is to this end that I provide three groups of responses to the conservation laws objection. First, I outline responses which take the ‘laws of nature’ as the proper entry point into the discussion. Secondly, I provide an analysis of those who argue that contemporary quantum physical data requires that the objection itself involves scientifically unjustified premises. Finally, I layout a philosophically oriented answer which argues that the objection is linguistically problematic since its demands on the dualist are categorically fallacious. From these groups of answers, I conclude that while the conservation laws objection has been arguably the most widely accepted objection against dualism, the objection is without philosophical justification.
Authors and Affiliations
Rashad Rehman
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP450872
- DOI 10.12681/conatus.15963
- Views 35
- Downloads 0
Meeting and Working with H.T. Engelhardt Jr.: An Inspiring Experience for a (once young) European Scholar
The author – a European “companion” of H. T. Engelhardt during the two last decades of the 20th century – describes his meetings with and impressions of Tris Engelhardt. He clarifies how open mindedness was the main conc...
Michel Foucault: The construction of the contemporary disciplinary subject
In his seminal Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison, Michel Foucault aims at outlining the historical course that led to the promulgation and consolidation of the institution of imprisonment as a means of punis...
Ethics of War and Ethics in War
The paper examines the justification of warfare. The main thesis is that war is very difficult to justify, and justification by invoking “justice” is not the way to succeed it. Justification and justness (“justice”) are...
Η φιλοσοφική σκέψη του Αριστοτέλη τότε και σήμερα: Η αριστοτελική οντολογία και τελεολογία
Η εργασία αυτή φιλοδοξεί να παρουσιάσει εκτενώς το πλαίσιο της αριστοτελικής μεταφυσικής και οντολογίας, καθώς και τον τρόπο με τον οποίο οι τελευταίες έχουν συνδράμει στη σχετική σκέψη και επιστήμη του σήμερα. Μέσω της...
Alexander Lee, Humanism and Empire, The Imperial Ideal in Fourteenth-Century Italy. Oxford University Press: Oxford 2018.
Book review: Alexander Lee, Humanism and Empire, The Imperial Ideal in Fourteenth-Century Italy (Oxford University Press: Oxford 2018). By Georgios Steiris, National and Kapodistrian University of Athens, Greece.