Do children need religious education? Discursive construction of children in talk shows by means of rhetorical questions
Journal Title: Journal of Comparative Research in Anthropology and Sociology - Year 2015, Vol 6, Issue 2
Abstract
My objective in this article is to analyze the discursive work done by rhetorical questions in attributing to the child-pupil, as the central character of the debate regarding religious education in schools, several characteristics, needs, rights and obligations in a “taken for granted” manner and thus serving certain ideological claims. Using a discourse analysis approach, I have analyzed several Romanian talk-shows centered on religious education in schools. During these shows children were discursively attributed with traits that often serve to support and promote certain ideological positions. Thus, children have been described most of the time as being vulnerable, immature, tending to abuse rights and liberties if they have the occasion, lacking judgment, but capable to learn Revelation, needing religious education as the only way to develop properly morally and spiritually. However, practicing these discourses and “portraits” in such public arenas may easily become permanent uncritical ideological labels, discursively associated with the children and their age specificities. In my view this possibility is highly increased by the use of rhetorical questions which hide these assumptions and labels behind the cover of obviousness. Moreover, the discursive work done by rhetorical question for supporting various ideological claims is shown to vary according to the addresser’s target: an opposing interlocutor or the general audience.
Authors and Affiliations
Cosmin Toth
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP41042
- DOI -
- Views 208
- Downloads 0
¿Mi cuerpo? ¡Mi vida! Voicing Latin American transgenders in Antwerp’s sex industry
Prostitution is a well-known universal social phenomenon, from anywhere and at all times, that attracts many migrants. Yet sex work is clearly not evenly integrated into society. After all, there are still existing dom...
Israeli football as an arena for post-colonial struggle: The case of Beitar Jerusalem FC
The current study endeavors to place the case of Beitar Jerusalem FC and its fans, as depicted in media, entertainment and public discourse in Israel, within an Orient-Occident theoretical framework. For this purpose t...
Hermeneutics of reason: the principle of common rationality as premise of understanding the Other(s)
The central argument defended in this paper is made up of two interconnected statements: i) that a minimally defined rationality is an anthropological constant, being shared by all conceivable human cultures; and ii) t...
A love letter
This letter tells the story of a young woman and a man I met during fieldwork with some university students in Colombo, Sri Lanka in 2007/08. Here, Hiranthi - the narrator - writes a letter to her boyfriend of nine mon...
Bruce Schneier (2015) Data and Goliath: The Hidden Battles to Collect Your Data and Control Your World, London & New York, W. W. Norton & Company
Scepticism was the attitude governing my state of mind when I stared reading this book but it vanished as soon as I realized it challenged one of my deepest beliefs, namely: My life is so ordinary that no one, in their...