Does representation matter? Teacher-provided tables and drawings as cognitive tools for solving non-routine word problems in primary school
Journal Title: European Journal of Science and Mathematics Education - Year 2018, Vol 0, Issue 0
Abstract
According to the German educational standards, students should be familiar with problem-solving as a general mathematical competency by the end of grade 4. Non-routine word problems are suitable tasks for mathematical problem-solving in elementary mathematics classes. They are characterized by the fact that the problem-solver cannot simply use well-trained algorithmic calculating procedures (Rasch, 2001). As a result, many students struggle with word problems in mathematics, especially with non-routine word problems (Hohn, 2012). Representation plays a central role in the process of problem-solving. It involves representing a problem situation adequately, constructing a mental model and comparing it in a dynamic and iterative process with the information externalized in the representation (Schnotz et al, 2011). This study aims to shed light on teacher-provided representations as cognitive tools for students when working on non-routine word problems. In an experimental study, we examined a sample of 67 primary school students who worked on six non-routine word problems with provided representations. The tasks were accompanied by a table or a drawing. Furthermore, the tables and drawings differed with regard to the amount of information provided. Statistical data analysis generated, among other findings, two results: Overall solution rates were low (10 to 24%). Tables and drawings facilitated the solution process differently depending on the type of word problem. Consequences for subsequent future research are discussed.
Authors and Affiliations
Timo Reuter *| Graduate School “Teaching and Learning Processes”, University of Koblenz-Landau, Landau, Germany, For correspondence: reutertimo@uni-landau.de, Wolfgang Schnotz| Department of General and Educational Psychology, University of Koblenz-Landau, Landau, Germany, Renate Rasch| Institute for Mathematics, University of Koblenz-Landau, Landau, Germany
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP8155
- DOI -
- Views 398
- Downloads 25
Math is like a lion hunting a sleeping gazelle: preservice elementary teachers’ metaphors of mathematics
Preservice elementary teachers hold a variety of beliefs about mathematics and mathematics learning, which influence their teaching. Previous research has shown that preservice elementary teachers believe that mathematic...
Conceptions of pupils of the primary on the topic of an electric circuit in three countries (Canada, France and Morocco)
Qualitative research conducted with 237 pupils from Canada, France, and Morocco, between 10 and 12 years of age, on the setting and functioning of simple electric circuits, demonstrates that similar explanatory systems o...
Adult science learners’ mathematical mistakes: An analysis of responses to computer-marked questions
Inspection of thousands of student responses to computer-marked assessment questions has brought insight into the errors made by adult distance learners of science. Most of the questions analysed were in summative use an...
Interactive digital documents to promote active learning of undergraduate mathematics
The Interactive Digital Documents (IDDs) are a set of materials designed to support the teaching/learning of Mathematical Analysis/Calculus for Engineering students. They are interactive and promote active participation...
An investigation into students’ difficulties in numerical problem solving questions in high school biology using a numeracy framework
The ‘mathematics problem’ is a well-known source of difficulty for students attempting numerical problem solving questions in the context of science education. This paper illuminates this problem from a biology education...