Duty of judge (judicial immunity): actual problems of legal regulation and practice application
Journal Title: Правова позиція - Year 2018, Vol 1, Issue
Abstract
The paper analyzes the latest constitutional mechanism for regulating the judge’s immunity. In the context of the study, the legal positions of the High Council for Justice (HCJ) regarding the removal of judicial immunity, which were reflected in relevant decisions for 2017, were analyzed. The author argues that domestic legislation needs some adjustments. In particular, the HCJ acting as a judicial (judicial) authority must establish whether the evidence presented by the party proves the circumstances, which indicate: 1) the existence of reasonable suspicion of committing a criminal offense by a judge suspected of a criminal offense; 2) the presence of sufficient grounds to believe that there is at least one of the risks stipulated in Article 177 of the CPC of Ukraine; 3) insufficiency of the use of milder preventive measures to prevent the risk or risks specified in the petition. The HCJ, in matters of removal of judge immunity, should perform judicial control function, and its decision to consent to the detention of a judge, his detention or arrest should be directly applicable, without further decisions of the investigating judge. An unjustified and unnecessary imposition (lay-out) of two jurisdictional jurisdictions: the HCJ and local courts (investigating judges) on judicial control in the detention and taking of judges in custody is considered to be groundless and unnecessary
Authors and Affiliations
С. В. Прилуцький
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP600677
- DOI -
- Views 76
- Downloads 0
Functional appointment of administrative-tort law in the Ukraine’s right system
The scientific article is devoted, firstly, to the discussion of the issues of jurisprudence on the place of administrative-tort law in the system of law of Ukraine. The conducted research points out that in the science...
Competition procedures for the determination of the private partner
The article is devoted to the analysis of legal regulation of the procedure for conducting a competition for the definition of a private partner within the framework of the procedure of public-private partnership. Curren...
Organizational and legal mechanism for developing customs business in Ukraine
The organizational and legal mechanism of the customs business is formed and practically functioning in the conditions of long and ambiguous practice of searching its optimal model. The organizational component of the cu...
Presumption of innocence: the cumulative legal ambush and its application in performing the function of protection
This article analyses the conceptual problems of improving the legal certainty of the presumption of innocence and its applications when using the institutions of legal assistance and protection in criminal proceedings....
Logical nature of indirect evidence in criminal process
The article is devoted to the study of the logical nature of indirect evidence in criminal process. The assertion that the indirect evidence logical understanding does not coincide with the indirect evidence concept cont...