Epistemologiczne problemy badań interdyscyplinarnych
Journal Title: Studia Europaea Gnesnensia - Year 2013, Vol 8, Issue
Abstract
In the paper, the author summarizes two basic types of methodologies which are characteristic of the humanities, including social sciences, and sciences as such, i.e. anti-naturalism and naturalism. Then she goes on to compare their differences, pointing to the inability of arriving at a reconciled and uniform paradigm at a theoretical level. At the same time, Angutek argues that in various interdisciplinary projects the theoretical constraints are overlooked in practice, and the rapprochement of both branches is successfully pursued at the level of high technological and communicative efficiency. The discussed theoretical incompatibilities and the practical effective combination and application of knowledge from different fields are demonstrated on the examples taken from humanistic geography by Tommy Carlstein and Yi-Fu Tuan, as well as from Anthony Giddens’s sociological application of this geography. The author concludes that classical theoretical discourses are not relevant, while practical interdisciplinary projects overcome that gap, yielding new descriptive terminology.
Authors and Affiliations
Dorota Angutek
Współpraca historyków i archeologów, czyli nieudana synteza dziejów Europy rzymskiej
Recenzja książki: Edward Bispham (red.), Europa rzymska, przeł. B. Mierzejewska,Świat Książki, Warszawa 2010, 432 s.
Historyczne formy waloryzacji ruin
On the historical and cultural plane, ruins are a lasting element of our landscape. The attitude towards ruins evolved, yet eventually, the 18th and 19th century “cult of ru-ins” allowed them to be perceived from the per...
Problemy metodologiczne w badaniach nad Celtami i celtyckością
For the past 20 years, Celtologists have lively debated the criterion of “Celtic¬ness”. This debate is a reflection of the general trend in the transformations taking place in the studies of barbarian peoples, resulting...
Consumption of Greek wines in Roman Italy
Consumption of Greek wines in Roman Italy
W labiryntach kulturowej hybrydowości
REC. KSIĄŻKI Homi K. Bhabha, Miejsca kultury, przekład Tomasz Dobrogoszcz, Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego, Kraków 2010, 322 s