Evolution: The Computer Systems Engineer Designing Minds
Journal Title: AVANT. Pismo awangardy filozoficzno-naukowej - Year 2011, Vol 0, Issue 2
Abstract
What we have learnt in the last six or seven decades about virtual machinery, as a result of a great deal of science and technology, enables us to offer Darwin a new defence against critics who argued that only physical form, not mental capabilities and consciousness could be products of evolution by natural selection. The defence compares the mental phenomena mentioned by Darwin’s opponents with contents of virtual machinery in computing systems. Objects, states, events, and processes in virtual machinery which we have only recently learnt how to design and build, and could not even have been thought about in Darwin’s time, can interact with the physical machinery in which they are implemented, without being identical with their physical implementation, nor mere aggregates of physical structures and processes. The existence of various kinds of virtual machinery (including both “platform” virtual machines that can host other virtual machines, e.g. operating systems, and “application” virtual machines, e.g. spelling checkers, and computer games) depends on complex webs of causal connections involving hardware and software structures, events and processes, where the specification of such causal webs requires concepts that cannot be defined in terms of concepts of the physical sciences. That indefinability, plus the possibility of various kinds of self-monitoring within virtual machinery, seems to explain some of the allegedly mysterious and irreducible features of consciousness that motivated Darwin’s critics and also more recent philosophers criticising AI. There are consequences for philosophy, psychology, neuroscience and robotics.
Authors and Affiliations
Aaron Sloman
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP103596
- DOI -
- Views 94
- Downloads 0
Our tender Middle Ages. Interview with Patrizia Bovi
W ciągłym ruchu... O Maxine Sheets-Johnstone. Wprowadzenie
„Jak to jest”. Czarna skrzynia Bałki a zalety i wady rozwiązania sensomotorycznego: Wprowadzenie
„Jak by tu wejść?” można zadać sobie pytanie, konfrontując się z ciemnością na progu. Wielu z nas od najmłodszych lat uczy się bać tego, co obce i nieznane. Jeśli na dodatek nieznane nie jest dostatecznie oświetlone, sta...
Précis of Mind in Life: Biology, Phenomenology, and the Sciences of Mind
The theme of this book is the deep continuity of life and mind. Where there is life there is mind, and mind in its most articulated forms belongs to life. Life and mind share a core set of formal or organizational proper...
What will you do to me when you see me? Perception as searching for affordances in the environment
Contemporary research on action-perception coupling draws on Gibson's concept of affordances. The text outlines the conceptual basis of this issue, showing how the notion of affordance is embraced in the theory of percep...