EXECUTION OF COURT DECISIONS IN TERMS OF THE RIGHT TO A FAIR TRIAL
Journal Title: Проблеми законності - Year 2018, Vol 141, Issue 141
Abstract
The article addresses the Ukrainian model of executive proceedings (which was recently updated as a result of constitutional reform in the justice sector) through the prism of the right to a fair trial, guaranteed by paragraph 1 of Art. 6 ECHR. Particular attention is paid to the analysis of the evaluative interpretation of this guarantee in case-law of the ECtHR, according to which an execution of court decisions is considered also as an element of other conventional rights, namely: a right to an effective remedy (Art. 13), a right to respect for private and family life (art. 8) and a right to peaceful enjoyment of his possessions (Art. 1 of 1st Additional Protocol to the ECHR). The author analyzes the pilot judgement of ECtHR «Yuriy Nikolaevich Ivanov v. Ukraine» and the judgement «Burmych v. Ukraine», in which the ECtHR diagnosed a systemic problem of non-enforcement of court decisions where the debtor is the State or state-owned enterprises. This problem at national level is caused by a variety of dysfunctions in the Ukrainian legal system, in particular, the lack of budgetary allocations, the bailiffs’ omissions and the shortcomings in the national legislation, authorities’ failure to take specific budgetary measures, the introduction of bans on the attachment and sale of property belonging to State-owned or controlled companies The article advocates a position according to which the national legislation of Ukraine needs further changes to ensure fulfillment of its international obligations. In particular, it is necessary to provide at national level an effective remedy of the right to a fair trial and execution of court decisions within a reasonable time in accordance with the requirements of Art. 13 ECHR.
Authors and Affiliations
Тетяна Цувіна
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP292032
- DOI 10.21564/2414-990x.141.131081
- Views 92
- Downloads 0
Preliminary inquiry as a tool for ensuring the unity of judicial practice: the nature and mechanisms of introduction in civil proceedings
In conditions of the need to continue the judicial reform in Ukraine, one of the most acute problems is the problem of the Supreme Court of Ukraine as the highest body in the system of courts of general jurisdiction, whi...
State agriculture policy of Ukraine on sustainable development of rural areas: legal aspects
One of the components of the state agricultural policy of Ukraine is to ensure sustainable rural development, which the international community recognized the existence of a strategy for the XXI century. The author found...
FAULT IN TORT LAW: MORAL JUSTIFICATION AND MATHEMATICAL EXPLICATION
The article has two main objectives: (1) to reveal why the fault principle is considered to be morally superior to no-fault liability in primitive law; and (2) to find out the essence of fault in modern tort law and then...
Peculiarities of the civil service in the national defense sector
<p><em>Considering the development of civil society as the driving force of the reform of the civil (public) service as a personalized basis for ensuring public administration in various spheres of social and political a...
Міжнародні механізми захисту права на життя в умовах збройних конфліктів
Стаття присвячена актуальній на сьогодні темі міжнародних механізмів захисту права на життя під час міжнародного та неміжнародного збройних конфліктів. Збільшення кількості збройних конфліктів у світі, а з ними й поруше...