From Dietary Guidelines to Dietary Guidance?
Journal Title: European Journal of Nutrition & Food Safety - Year 2015, Vol 5, Issue 4
Abstract
One challenge is to make food consumption healthful and sustainable. Tools to achieve this include science-based documented dietary advice (here: 'dietary guidelines'), and policy-based initiatives and legislation (here: 'dietary guidance'). These two scientific and political tools operate independently, which may be counterproductive, especially if the future gives rise to high-impact scenarios of food crisis. This paper analyses, based on empirical trend data, the potential of dietary guidelines and guidance, and provides suggestions for these to align. Trend-analyses and empirical data point out that dietary guidelines, although relevant, achieve limited uptake by the consumer. Scientists apparently lack the management tools and communication channels to effectively reach the consumer, and thus major changes are not expected. By contrast, emerging issues such as the obesogenic environment and climate change are likely to call for greater involvement of policy-makers. This paper therefore advocates alignment of science and food policy. First, dietary guidelines, used for individual health promoting purposes, should be calibrated on global considerations. Guidelines on red meat consumption are recommended, as red meat consumption is a burden on both health and sustainability. Second, dietary guidance, used for global health and sustainability promoting purposes, should be calibrated on empowering the individual. Guidance in creating self-sufficient local food networks is recommended, as self-sufficient local food networks address both health and sustainability.
Authors and Affiliations
Egbert Clevers, Miriam Urlings
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP350382
- DOI 10.9734/EJNFS/2015/17435
- Views 84
- Downloads 0
Food Risk Perceptions of Women in Rural and Urban Households- A Study in India
Aims: The current study attempted to examine risk perceptions related to safety of various commonly consumed foods and perceived health hazards associated with such risk perceptions among home food preparers. Study Desi...
Antioxidant and Neuroprotective Effect of Organic and Conventional White Grape Juices on Oxidative Stress Induced by Sodium Azide in Cerebral Cortex of Rats
Aims: Diet plays an important role in the prevention of some diseases related to oxidative stress. Although the beneficial effects of a moderate intake of wine are well known, information about the antioxidant properties...
An Australian Process that Assesses Country BSE Food Safety Risk
Background: Bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) is a transmissible, fatal neurodegenerative disease of cattle. Recognised in 1986, the disease causes a spongiform degeneration of the neural network in the brain and sp...
The Effect of Mothers’ and Fathers’ Food Preferences on Children’s Preferences with Their Attitude
Aims: Early childhood is most crucial for establishing eating habits; therefore, controlling the preferences of young children is critical. This study investigated the relationship between mothers’ and fathers’ food pref...
Origin of the Recommended Intake of L-Histidine by Infants
Background: In mid-2012, Food Standards Australia New Zealand (FSANZ) received an application to change the Australia New Zealand Food Standards Code so that the minimum L-histidine content of infant formula sold in Aust...