From Faulty Biochemical Assumptions to Poor Diagnostic Performance: Reflections on the Failure of DNA Microarrays to Become a Reliable Clinical Diagnostic Tool
Journal Title: Journal of Advances in Medicine and Medical Research - Year 2014, Vol 4, Issue 27
Abstract
Since their inception about two decades ago, DNA microarrays have been considered as a great hope in translational research and personalized medicine. Although DNA microarrays for gene expression profiling proved to be an indispensable tool in the laboratory settings, their applications as an instrument for clinical diagnostics have not yet produced tangible results. In this paper, we convey the idea that, apart from notoriously poor reproducibility and complexities of experimental validations, there exist other reasons hindering clinical application of DNA microarrays. These reasons are rooted in the very core of the DNA microarrays methodology, that is, in faulty biochemical assumptions underlying microarray measurements. A key premise the microarray measurements are based on is that mRNA abundances harvested from the eukaryotic cytoplasm are indicative of the activity levels of corresponding genes. There are at least two reasons why this premise is questionable. First, each transcription is supported by a number of transcription factors expressed by many genes. Due to this reason, relations between the transcription rates of genes and the mRNA abundances are the 'many-to-one', not the 'one-to-one'; therefore, abnormality in a certain mRNA abundance does not unequivocally indicate abnormality of the gene bearing its complimentary code. Second, mRNA copy numbers in cytoplasm are regulated by a number of epigenetic factors among which the post-transcriptional mRNA stability is of primary importance. Abnormal concentration of certain mRNA may result from deviant mRNA stability, thus mimicking, but having nothing to do with, presumed abnormality in transcription rates of corresponding genes. An instrument built upon so poorly understood biochemical basis can hardly serve as a reliable tool in the delicate task of diagnosis of human disease in clinical settings.
Authors and Affiliations
Simon Rosenfeld
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP349025
- DOI 10.9734/BJMMR/2014/9661
- Views 79
- Downloads 0
Determinants of Public Satisfaction and Perception of National Healthcare Services Availability in Jordan: A Patient Survey
Aims: This study aims to assess Jordanian public satisfaction with healthcare services. Study Design: A descriptive cross-sectional survey design was used. Place and Duration of Study: Data were collected from 571 Jordan...
The Pirani Scoring System is Effective in Assessing Severity and Monitoring Treatment of Clubfeet in Children
Background: Pirani scoring system is one of the classification systems and is simple, easy to use in the management of clubfoot; however, there is paucity of studies using Pirani system to determine the severity and moni...
Ascitic Antigen CA125: Study of Dissociaton Forms and its Final - Stem Structure
Aim: Study of dissociation forms of the ascites antigen СА125 and its stem structure – the final form of its dissociation. Study Design: Resarch paper. Place and Duration оf Study: Department of biochemistry, N.I. Pirogo...
Complicated Fracture and Resorption of an Osteochondroma
Aims: To describe two unusual complications of a typical solitary pedunculated femoral osteochondroma that included a distal fracture of the exostosis and a missed fragment following surgical treatment as well as to eval...
What Can Physicians Propose to Help Children with Aspecific Cough? Review of the Literature
Aims: New cough guidelines recommend a wait, watch and review attitude without any prescription of medication. However, practitioner adhesion is low. We aimed to search what alternative physician could proposed to drug p...