Hospital performance reports based on severity adjusted mortality rates in patients with cirrhosis depend on the method of risk adjustment
Journal Title: Annals of Hepatology - Year 2012, Vol 11, Issue 4
Abstract
Background. Hospital outcome report cards are used to judge provider performance, including for liver transplantation. We aimed to determine the impact of the choice of risk adjustment method on hospital rankings based on mortality rates in cirrhotic patients. Material and methods. We identified 68,426 cirrhotic patients hospitalized in the Nationwide Inpatient Sample database. Four risk adjustment methods (the Charlson/Deyo and Elixhauser algorithms, Disease Staging, and All Patient Refined Diagnosis Related Groups)were used in logistic regression models for mortality. Observed to expected (O/E) death rates were calculated for each method and hospital. Statistical outliers with higher or lower than expected mortality were identified and rankings compared across methods. Results. Unadjusted mortality rates for the 553 hospitals ranged from 1.4 to 30% (overall, 10.6%). For 163 hospitals (29.5%), observed mortality differed significantlyfrom expected when judged by one or more, but not all four, risk adjustment methods (25.9% higher than expected mortality and 3.6% lower than expected mortality). Only 28% of poor performers and 10% of superior performers were consistently ranked as such by all methods. Agreement between methods as to whether hospitals were flagged as outliers was moderate (kappa 0.51-0.59), except the Charlson/Deyo and Elixhauser algorithms which demonstrated excellent agreement (kappa 0.75). Conclusions. Hospital perfor-mance reports for patients with cirrhosis require sensitivity to the method of risk adjustment. Depending upon the method, up to 30% of hospitals may be flagged as outliers by one, but not all methods. These discrepancies could have important implications for centers erroneously labeled as high mortality outliers.
Authors and Affiliations
Robert Myers, James Hubbard, Abdel Shaheen, Elijah Dixon, Gilaad Kaplan
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP78171
- DOI -
- Views 130
- Downloads 0
Mean platelet volume is a useful indicator of systemic inflammation in cirrhotic patients with ascitic fluid infection
[b]Aim[/b]. Ascitic fluid infection (AFI) consists primarily of two variants, namely, culture-negative neutrocytic ascites and spontaneous bacterial peritonitis (SBP). Mean platelet volume (MPV) has begun to be used as a...
Kava hepatotoxicity - a clinical review
This review critically analyzes the clinical data of patients with suspected kava hepatotoxicity and suggests recommendations for minimizing risk. Kava is a plant (Piper methysticum) of the pepper family Piperaceae, and...
Salmonella sp Group A: A rare cause of bacterascites. A case report
Bacterascites (BA) is a minimally studied and defined entity. Its prognosis and clinical course are not well defined, and currently there are no management guidelines. We present a rare cause of BA in which Salmonella sp...
The liver is the key organ for the development of metabolic syndrome
Cellular microRNA and the tumorigenesis of hepatocellular carcinoma