Human Rights, Religious Identity, and the Private-Public Distinction
Journal Title: The Journal of Human Rights - Year 2007, Vol 1, Issue 2
Abstract
It is thought that by respecting an adequately drawn private (or personal) sphere, political institutions can give sufficient freedom to people to develop their distinct cultural and religious identities without compromising human rights values. The public sphere is where rights are observed, the private is where rights claims have no role. However, the distinction between the private and the public sphere is a difficult one to draw. In this paper we argue that there is no pre-theoretical notion of the public and private, but rather that the boundaries between private and public are themselves sensitive to the moral theory of rights one adopts. So rather than rights being understood in terms of the public and the private, the public and private distinction should be understood in terms of rights. As evidence for the lack of an independent distinction we cite a study of cases in European courts, where the public-private distinction was paramount in adjudicating the rights of religious minorities. چکیده در این مقاله، تحلیلی از مسئلة اصلی نظریه و رویة قضایی حقوق بشر را بسط می‌دهیم. مشکل به برخورد با هویت دینی در دولت‌هایی مربوط می‌شود که مدعی دفاع از معیارهای حقوق بشر در اروپا هستند. این مشکل - به عنوان مثال - خود را در قالب ممنوعیت اعمال مذهبی خاصی نشان داده است که تصور می‌شود اصول مطابق با مبانی دولت در برخی از حکومت‌های اروپایی را نقض می‌کند. از جملة این اعمال مذهبی می‌توان به پوشیدن روسری و سایر موارد مذهبی توسط کسانی که وظایفی دولتی برعهده دارند (مانند کارمندان دولت و معلمین) یا کسانی که به اماکن عمومی وارد می‌شوند (مانند محصّلان مدارس و دانشگاه‌های دولتی)، اشاره کرد.
Authors and Affiliations
Saladin Meckled-Garcia, Basak Cali
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP302490
- DOI -
- Views 138
- Downloads 0
Habermas, Religion and Human Rights
In my paper, I take as a specific example of the relationship between religion and human rights in the work of Jürgen Habermas, asking if there is any possible relationship between religion and the foundations of human...
Basic Differences and Shared Human Rights
While human beings are of unity as human beings, they live in some sort of plurality (in terms of their believes, interests, races, languages, etc) both being inevitable realities. Do human beings have shared rights to...
Limits of Corporal Punishment of Children by Parents from Legal and Jurisprudential Perspectives
Article 59, paragraph 1 of the Islamic penal code of the Islamic Republic of Iran recognizes the parental treatment in the form of punishment, as a justification as long as it is reasonable. This legal right of parents t...
Can Women’s Rights be Human Rights?
Several international human rights documents purport to affirm women’s rights. But can women’s rights really be human rights? The problem is not whether women can possess human rights. Women are human beings and therefor...
Theory of Right – Duty
Studying the history of philosophic thoughts, one finds out that more attention has been paid to “right” than its opposite term, “duty”. However, this issue has little been under discussion that if a single person comes...