Human Rights Waiver in Criminal Proceedings in Terms of the European Court of Human Rights: ‘Russian Cases’
Journal Title: Journal of Advanced Research in Social Sciences - Year 2020, Vol 3, Issue 4
Abstract
The article investigates the general position of the European Court of Human Rights on the admissibility and validity of the waiver of rights, the features of the European mechanism for protecting human rights in case of the waiver of the right; studies the case-law practices in criminal cases of the Court in relation to Russia where the Court considered the presence/absence of the waiver of the right. The practice of the ECHR reveals the widespread occurrence of human rights violations in the Russian criminal proceedings with the alleged waiver of the right in the framework of criminal procedure. These includes the situations when the Government claimed that the Applicant had waived his/her right and the Applicant did not agree with this fact and insisted that he had been deprived of the opportunity to exercise his/her right. According to the ECHR, violations of human rights established in the Convention are related not only to shortcomings in the legal system but also to improper law enforcement that does not comply with the Convention requirements. Based on the analysis of the ECHR’s general approaches to the waiver of the right, the authors revealed the compliance of the Russian criminal procedure with the requirements of the Court to the waiver of the right and the guarantees established for it. To achieve the objectives in the HUDOC database of the European Court, using search requests we identified cases against Russia considered by the Chamber and the Grand Chamber, in which the ECHR examined the issue of the presence/absence of the waiver of the right in the criminal procedure. As a result, 40 judgments in which the Court directly considered the issue of the presence/absence of the waiver of the right in the criminal procedure in Russia were selected. We studied and analysed the selected judgments.
Authors and Affiliations
Irina Chebotareva, Olesia Pashutina, Irina Revina
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP743701
- DOI https://doi.org/10.33422/jarss.v3i4.535
- Views 13
- Downloads 0
English Language Proficiency and its Impact on Professional Identity, Operational Skills, and Gender Dynamics among Police Cadets in Greece
This study explores the impact of English language proficiency on professional identity, operational skills, and gender dynamics among cadets at the Hellenic Police Officers School in Greece. It addresses three main rese...
Gender Differences and the Effects of Sibling Composition on Parents' Educational Expectations: Findings from a Case of China
This research aims to examine gender differences in parents’ expectations for the education of their children in China. With rich information from the 2013/14 wave of China Education Panel Survey Data, this study used th...
Argentine Chaotic Term Length Series in an American Historical Context
The political stability of a government system is crucial for achieving social, economic, and cultural growth of a people. Among other things, political stability depends on the norms that come from a state of rights. Se...
The Demand for Freedom and Equality in the Street Below the Movement of Woman, Life, Freedom (August 2022)
This research, which explores the role of street protests in the freedom and equality movement of the 2022 urban uprising, was conducted using a secondary analysis approach and references to related sources, documents an...
The Nature-Nurture Controversy: The Nucleo-genre Paradigm as a Means of Understanding Gender
The relation between the sexes has long been founded on the basis of masculine domination. Interpreting biological differences as evidence of male superiority, social institutions - the family, religious and educational...