Individualised training duration induces similar physiological and performance benefits at different intensities
Journal Title: Journal of Science and Cycling - Year 2014, Vol 3, Issue 2
Abstract
Background: When comparing the effects of different training intensities, studies often standardise for energy expenditure. These studies tend to suggest that high intensity training (HIT) provides greater or similar benefits as moderate intensity training (MOD). However, the time (and energy expenditure) that an individual can sustain at the same relative intensity is highly variable. The possible impact of this variability on response to training has been largely ignored. Purpose: The aim of this study was to compare the effects of three different exercise intensities; HIT, MOD and a combination of the two (MIX) when the training duration is individualised. Methods: Participants were sedentary and recreationally active males and females training < 4h/wk. Thirty-four participants (mean ± SD; age 28 ± 9yr, mass 75.8 ± 12kg) were randomly assigned to the MOD (n=11; VO2max = 3.37 ± 0.79 l.min-1); HIT (n=12; VO2max = 3.12 ± 0.58 l.min-1) and MIX (n=11; VO2max = 3.75 ± 0.67 l.min-1) training groups. Before and after 4-wks of supervised training (4 times/wk) we measured VO2max and maximal minute power, time-to-exhaustion at 60% of maximal minute power, and cycling efficiency. The MOD group trained at 60% of maximal minute power in blocks of 5-min and 1-min passive recovery. The training duration was individualised to 100% of their pre-training time-to-exhaustion test. The HIT group trained at 100% maximal minute power for 2-min repetitions with 3-min recovery. The duration was set as the maximum number of repetitions completed in the first session and this was used as a baseline for subsequent sessions. The MIX group completed two MOD and two HIT sessions each week. All participants were encouraged to complete an extra block or repetition after every two training sessions. The effects of training were analysed using a two-way mixed ANOVA (time; training group). The level of significance was set at P<0.05. Effect size for each statistical test was also calculated as partial eta squared (ηp2). Results: Average total time spent exercising for the HIT, MOD and MIX groups was ~ 6h, 16h and 10.5h respectively. All three training groups significantly increased their VO2max, maximal minute power and time-to-exhaustion following 4-weeks of training (P<0.05). However, there were no significant differences between groups for VO2max (P=0.378, ηp2=0.06); maximal minute power (P=0.634, ηp2=0.03) and time-to-exhaustion (P=0.582, ηp2=0.03) (P<0.05). There was an interaction effect for cycling efficiency (P=0.02, ηp2=0.22). A follow up test revealed no difference between groups at baseline (all P>0.590) and a significant increase in cycling efficiency for the MIX group only (P=0.009). Inter-individual differences in training responses were high for all variables. Discussion: When training durations are tailored to each individual, similar improvements are found in VO2max, maximal minute power and time-to-exhaustion, despite a substantially greater time spent training at MOD intensity. A significantly greater increase in cycling efficiency following MIX training warrants further investigation, with research suggesting that training based on a polarised distribution might be more beneficial, avoiding training monotony (Neal et al., 2013: Journal of Applied Physiology, 144 (4) 461-471). Conclusion: These findings support the contention that individualised HIT and MIX are time-efficient training strategies inducing similar changes when compared to MOD.
Authors and Affiliations
SL Coakley| Endurance Research Group, School of Sport and Exercise Sciences, University of Kent, United Kingdom, L Passfield| Endurance Research Group, School of Sport and Exercise Sciences, University of Kent, United Kingdom
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP2840
- DOI -
- Views 373
- Downloads 20
An online survey using social media investigating the use of kinesiology type tape and McConnell type tape with clinicians who treat cycling related knee pain
Background: From high profile events such as the Tour De France and the Olympics, it is noticeable that kinesiology type taping (KTT) is used widely within elite cycling for treatment of knee pain. Taping is a clinical t...
Validity of the Wahoo KICKR Power Trainer and Reliability of a 4 km Cycle Time Trial
Purpose: To assess the validity of power and the reliability of a 4 km cycle time trial (TT) using the Wahoo KICKR Power Trainer. Methods: The Wahoo KICKR power output was assessed using a dynamic calibration rig (DCR...
The reliability and validity of the 3-minute critical power test in linear and isokinetic mode
Background: Exercise testing for cyclists provides key information when setting training and race strategies. Shorter testing protocols are favored by coaches and recently it has been suggested that critical power (CP) a...
Comparison of physiological and perceptual responses to a maximal exhaustive test performed on the SRM and the Cyclus2 ergometer
Background: No cycle ergometer perfectly replicates the physiological demands and movement patterns associated with real world cycling (Abbiss et al., 2009: International Journal of Sports Medicine, 30(2), 107-112). The...
GPS-Based Evaluation of Activity Profiles in Elite Downhill Mountain Biking and the Influence of Course Type
This study aimed to profile the activity patterns of elite downhill (DH) mountain bikers during off-road descending, and to determine the influence of course types on activity patterns. Six male elite DH mountain bikers...