Interpretive Truth and Interpretive Validity: Remarks on Danto’s Idea of “Constitutive Interpretation”
Journal Title: Meta: Research in Hermeneutics, Phenomenology, and Practical Philosophy - Year 2009, Vol 1, Issue 1
Abstract
Given an interpretive ontology of the artwork, exemplified by Danto’s “constitutive interpretation” thesis, the present paper considers a fundamental “obscurity” at the heart of the artistic (contemporary) phenomenon – the ontological confusion between the material and the semantic “body“ of an artwork. For Danto, the material object of an artwork is nothing but the embodiment of an intended meaning, metaphorically expressed by the artist and waiting to be reconstructed by its audience. Therefore, an epistemic concept of truth, understood as interpretive validity, seems to be required for maintaining the identity of the artwork. In this paper, I am trying to show that Danto’s epistemic conditions of interpretive validity are too strong to be maintained in the (ordinary) experience of an artwork. Instead, using the difference between understanding and interpretation, I try to show, following Shusterman and Gadamer, that the experience of the artwork could be democratically reconstructed in the frame of a pluralistic view of the concept of interpretive validity. The necessity of a “hermeneutic” concept of “truth” is thus maintained, given that the artwork and its experience by a concrete public would not be dissociated.
Authors and Affiliations
Cristian Nae
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP84846
- DOI -
- Views 164
- Downloads 0
On the New Faces of Democracy
Geneviève Nootens, Souveraineté démocratique, justice et mondialisation. Essai sur la démocratie libérale et le cosmopolitisme, Montréal : Liber, 2010
Pratiques de la ville et inconscient urbain : déplacements de l’utopie dans le discours critique de l’urbanisme
This article tackles the critical approaches to urbanism as power-knowledge developed since the 1960-1970 based on the instruments of semiological and psychoanalytical analysis. From this viewpoint, we come back to the c...
Menaces of Liberal Education: M. Oakeshott
In the present text I discuss Michael Oakeshott’s idea of liberal education and its main menace, authority. By identifying two ways of examining the issue of authority, I launch two different perspectives on this issue....
The white comprehension: Phenomenological hermeneutics and revelation of the poetal flesh
Built upon the basic postulates of phenomenologic hermeneutics, this approach discusses the distinction between the poetic and the poetal body, investigating the possibility of the latter to reveal itself to the comprehe...
Action, text, culture: Reflections on hermeneutical anthropology between Clifford Geertz and Paul Ricoeur
The paper investigates the phenomenon of foreignness and its understanding in ethnographic and philosophical context. The role of a phenomenologicalhermeneutic conception of text and action in bridging the gap between th...