Is presumed consent an ethically acceptable way of obtaining organs for transplant?
Journal Title: Journal of the Intensive Care Society - Year 2019, Vol 20, Issue 2
Abstract
The near-universal acceptance of cadaveric organ donation has been based on the provision of explicit consent by the donor while alive, either in the form of a formal opt-in or informal discussion of wishes with next of kin. Despite the success of transplantation programmes based on explicit consent, the ongoing imbalance between demand and supply of organs for transplantation has prompted calls for more widespread introduction of laws validating presumed consent with facility for opt-out as a means of increasing organ availability. The Department of Health (UK) has recently concluded a consultation on the introduction of such a law for England. This article explores the debate on presumed consent from an ethical point of view and summarises the key arguments on both sides of the ethical divide.
Authors and Affiliations
Pradeep Kumar Prabhu
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP679547
- DOI 10.1177/1751143718777171
- Views 65
- Downloads 0
Mortality and long-term dialysis requirement among elderly continuous renal replacement therapy patients in a tertiary referral intensive care unit
Elderly patients are frequently considered poor candidates for continuous renal replacement therapy in intensive care units, but with little evidence base.
This month in JICS
The incidence of cardiac arrest in the intensive care unit: A systematic review and meta-analysis
The incidence of cardiac arrest in the intensive care unit (ICU-CA) has not been widely reported. We undertook a systematic review and meta-analysis of studies reporting the incidence of cardiac arrest in adult, general...
A practical guide to medical ethics for intensivists: Part 2
A doctor’s duty in advising patients changed significantly in March 2015 when the Supreme Court ruled in Montgomery v Lanarkshire Health Board. The decision is an important one for all doctors.
Severe meningococcal serogroup W sepsis presenting as myocarditis: A case report and review of literature
The global incidence of invasive meningococcal disease due to serogroup W (MenW) has risen over the last decade. The following case emphasises the atypical features of MenW meningococcaemia, which included myocarditis, a...