Islamic Modernists and Discourse on Reason as a Reconciliatory Argument between Islam and the Western Enlightenment

Journal Title: International Journal of Islamic Thought - Year 2015, Vol 7, Issue 1

Abstract

This article examines the debates on the relationship between Islam and reason during the nineteenth century and early twentieth century. It argues that these debates were transnational but were largely influenced by similar debates in the Western tradition. It also affirms that modernists used discourse on reason to reconcile Islam with Western Enlightenment. The article illustrates the various mechanisms which Islamic modernists implemented to facilitate such reconciliation. These mechanisms include rationalization of miracles, contesting the concept of prophethood, and rejecting the scholarship of Islamic jurisprudence and theology. Based on writings by several Islamic modernists, such as their biographies of Prophet Muhammad, Quran commentaries, and magazine articles in different Islamic countries, I ascribe these mechanisms to a gap between logic and experimental thought, a gap which seeped into the mind of Islamic modernists under the influence of Western contemporary thinkers. While this discourse claims compatibility between Islam and Western Enlightenment, it also resists the binary of the sacred and the secular, a major legacy of the Western Enlightenment.

Authors and Affiliations

ASMAHAN SALLAH

Keywords

Related Articles

Crescent and Electoral Strength: Islamic Party Portrait of Reform Era In Indonesia

The establishment of Islamic political parties in the reform era in Indonesia after the fall of Suharto (1998), considered as resurgence of political stream. There are several factors that led to the revival of Islamic p...

Sorotan Literatur Perbandingan Gagasan Sastera Islami Sayyid Sayyid `Abd al-Raziq dan Mohd Affandi Hassan

Difference of views in understanding the idea of Islamic literature and criticism involves two different cultures often occur in the field of comparative literature world. Yet despite the differences and inequalities, st...

Arab-Israeli Six-Day War 1967 through the Perspective of the Realism Theory

Realism approach has dominated the studies of world politics and international relations since the last of the World War II and until the start of the Cold War era. The focus of this study is to look into the factors tha...

Validity and Reliability of the Religious Belief Instrument

This article discussed the construct validity and reliability of faith appreciation questionnaire. The instrument was developed based on past literature, expert opinion and research objectives. Expert interview has been...

Revisiting the Life and Thought of Dr. Burhanuddin al-Helmy

Burhanuddin al-Helmy is the least known name in Malaysian history. However, his role and thought cannot simply be dismissed although some of it were considered as controversial, and him be labelled as radical Malay leade...

Download PDF file
  • EP ID EP122299
  • DOI -
  • Views 124
  • Downloads 0

How To Cite

ASMAHAN SALLAH (2015). Islamic Modernists and Discourse on Reason as a Reconciliatory Argument between Islam and the Western Enlightenment. International Journal of Islamic Thought, 7(1), 11-24. https://europub.co.uk/articles/-A-122299