KEIMANAN ABU THALIB (Studi Komparatif Terhadap Tafsir Ibn Kasir dan Tafsir al-Mizan)
Journal Title: Jurnal At-Tibyan: Jurnal Ilmu Alquran dan Tafsir - Year 2017, Vol 2, Issue 1
Abstract
Abu Talib's faith in the realm of Islamic thought still has a very long debate. Some scholars have claimed that he is an infidel, while others have claimed that he was a believer. Abu Talib was not uncommon also mixed up in political issues at the time of the power held by Mu'awiya sought to discredit Ali and his family. In the Koran, there are many verses that are considered by some scholars that the verses 113-114, al-Qasas verse 56, Surah al-An'am verse 26, and other letters relating to the faith of Abu Talib.The study was written as a reflection of the author's interest in knowing more about the subject by focusing Ibn Kathir's interpretation of the study as a Sunni interpretation and interpretation Tabataba'i as a homage to Shiite interpretation. The equation of these two interpreters is that Ibn Kathir explicitly says that these verses descend are addressed to Abu Talib (The Prophet's Uncle), who tells of Abu Talib's refusal to recite the two sentences of the shahadah at the end of his life, and still holds to his former religion Religion Abdul Mutallib. So also with T{abat{aba’i who said that Abu Talib died in a state of no faith and still hold on to the religion of his ancestors. While the location of the differences between them is contained in the interpretation of the letter al-An'am Ibn Kathir says the verse goes down with regard to Abu Talib who defends the Prophet to carry out his da'wah. T{abat{aba’i is different from Ibn Kathir in the explanation of his riwayah, namely the interpretation of 'Iyasi and Qumi's commentary, he says from the line of Ahl Bait that Abu Talib is a believer based on his evidence and his sayings. Essentially these two interpretations are the same, the most notable distinction lies only in the flow they profess, Ibn Kathir as a Sunni interpreter, T{abat{aba’i as a Shiite interpreter.
Authors and Affiliations
Diyan Yusri
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP416456
- DOI -
- Views 107
- Downloads 0
AMIN AL-KHULI DAN METODE TAFSIR SASTRAWI ATAS ALQURAN
This article discusses about the biography of Ami>n al-Khu>li> and his thought; literary interpretation of the Quran (TafsirSastrawi). He offers this method because the Quran is Arabic(‘arabiyyunmubi>n). Therefore, the u...
KONSEP WAHYU DALAM ALQURAN (KAJIAN SEMANTIK)
Bagi para nabi yang berada pada tingkatan yang lebih rendah, malaikat yang turun kepada mereka baik dalam alam sadar atau mimpi, akan bersemanyam di daya khayal mereka dan hakikat gaib (wahyu) yang turun dari Hadhrat ‘Il...
KEIMANAN ABU THALIB (Studi Komparatif Terhadap Tafsir Ibn Kasir dan Tafsir al-Mizan)
Abu Talib's faith in the realm of Islamic thought still has a very long debate. Some scholars have claimed that he is an infidel, while others have claimed that he was a believer. Abu Talib was not uncommon also mixed up...
ISSUES ON WOMEN AND PROBLEMS IN WORKPLACE FROM ISLAMIC POINT OF VIEW
The globalization and economic growth develop bigger chance especially to women to take a part in playing their role. Women education and strength are well established nowadays which can be potentially empowered in many...
WOMEN INTERPRETATIONS ON QUR’AN, ISLAMIC INSTITUTIONS AND COMMUNITIES
This paper examines ideas raised by several Muslim feminist to overlook Islam from women perspectives that shed a light especially on the Qur’an, Islamic institutions and social practices of Islamic teaching in Muslim s...