Kryzys idei trójpodziału władzy. Kilka uwag na tle współczesnego sporu o Trybunał Konstytucyjny w Polsce – perspektywa filozoficznoprawna
Journal Title: Studia Prawno-Ekonomiczne - Year 2017, Vol 0, Issue
Abstract
Almost in every book concerning a problem of law and order and democracy the principle of the tripartite separation of power is indicated as one of the basic principles of the democratic state based on the rule of law. Last months in Poland’s legal and political culture a problem appeared which is widely called ‘a dispute over the Constitutional Tribunal’, ‘a dispute over democracy’ or ‘a crisis regarding the Constitutional Tribunal’. In my opinion, it is not only a political dispute as it is most often presented in the media but it is a philosophical issue difficult to resolve. Its explanation and potential solution must reach basic means of legal philosophy and the grounds of legal and political thinking. In this article I challenge a thesis that the dispute is immanently connected with our legal culture and involves a distinctive position of positive law in that culture with an attempt of creating jurisprudence by legal positivism.
Authors and Affiliations
Tomasz Bekrycht
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP233909
- DOI 10.26485/SPE/2017/104/1
- Views 77
- Downloads 0
„Promieniowanie” konstytucji
The text deals with the phenomenon of influencing the principles expressed in the Constitution on the other branches of law, in particular to the private law. The starting point is to present the origins in jurisdiction...
Sir Robert Filmer. Sam przeciwko wszystkim! Część I
Sir Robert Filmer was an English political theorist who defended absolutism and the divine right of kings criticizing Hobbes, Milton, Grotius, Bellarimine, Suarez and Aristotle. Filmer’s theory is founded upon the statem...
John Lilburne – człowiek, który za bardzo uwierzył w wolność
Lewellerzy byli ruchem politycznym działającym podczas angielskiej wojny domowej, który opowiadał się za radykalnymi reformami politycznymi, ponieważ ich Agreement of the People zawierały prawdopodobnie pierwsze nowożytn...
Analiza porównawcza mierników prawnej ochrony pracowników
The aim of the article was to compare commonly used measures of the employment protection legislation. The study was conducted for the indicators published by the OECD, the Heritage Foundation, the Fraser Institute and t...
Pośrednie wykorzystanie prawa rzymskiego w tzw. Traktacie o prawie (S. Th. I–II, qq. 90–97) św. Tomasza z Akwinu / Indirect Use of the Roman Law in the so-called Treatise on Law (S. Th I–II, qq. 90–97) by Saint Thomas Aquinas
The article concerns the issue of indirect use of the Roman law by Saint Thomas in so-called Treatise on Law. Although Aquinas mentioned the authority of numerous ancient authors – both pagan and Christian – the influenc...