Leading over the Long Run: Rhetorical Consequentialism and Rhetorical Leadership
Journal Title: Res Rhetorica - Year 2019, Vol 6, Issue 2
Abstract
Because the goals leaders and organizations seek typically require persistent engagement over time, rhetorical leadership has as a central concern the long-term consequences of the leader’s rhetorical choices. Although traditional rhetorical theory downplayed this long-term perspective in favor of the singular rhetorical engagement (such as a speech), rhetorical theorists have begun considering the rhetorical implications of persuasion wrought over the long-run. This essay applies rhetorical consequentialism, a theoretical perspective developed by the author, to explain the orientation and strategies the rhetorical leader must consider in longterm persuasion. Leaders must be concerned about consistency over time to avoid charges of waffl ing, delusion, lying, hypocrisy, and the like if they are to maintain their ethos and that of their organizations. They also should take positive steps to create the symbolic and material conditions for rhetorical success over the long run. The essay describes „constraint avoidance” strategies that limit inconsistencies over time, as well as „stage-setting” strategies that prepare the symbolic and material ground for future rhetorical success. The essay draws examples from American political rhetoric, especially that of Donald Trump, to illuminate these strategies. The essay concludes by considering the challenges and prospects of such strategies.
Authors and Affiliations
Clarke Rountree
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP602039
- DOI 10.29107/rr2019.2.1
- Views 99
- Downloads 0
Rhetorical Aftershocks of Trump’s Ascendency: Salvation by Demolition and Deal Making
This essay offers an early assessment, after the first 100 days, of Donald Trump’s bewildering ascendency to the US presidency. It examines his apocalyptic rhetoric as a spectacle of salvation by demolition and deal maki...
Prawdopodobieństwo w retoryce rzymskiej
Probability in the Roman rhetoric. This article considers the question of probability in the Roman rhetoric. The modern scholars turn their attention fi rst of all to Greek probability. This essay try to show that also R...
Watching people playing games: A survey of presentational techniques in most popular game-vlogs
This study is dedicated to the mechanisms of popularity of YouTube vloggers that upload gaming videos. The presentational techniques used in those videos are examined to identify the reasons of their popularity and the t...
Report/Sprawozdanie: II Ogólnopolski Konkurs Debat Oksfordzkich Wysoki poziom dziennikarstwa w Polsce a źródło świadomości społecznej
sprawozdanie
Justifying a recommendation: tell a story or present an argument?
In the deliberative genre there is a complex ‘playground’ of choices to present a recommendation; a rhetorician has to determine his or her position. Relevant dimensions are the coerciveness of the recommendation and the...