Mentalization and theory of mind in borderline personality organization: exploring the differences between affective and cognitive aspects of social cognition in emotional pathology
Journal Title: Psychiatria Polska - Year 2014, Vol 48, Issue 3
Abstract
Aim : This article addresses the problem of explaining emotional pathology (levels of personality organization) using the concepts of theory of mind (ToM) and mentalization. Although these terms are used interchangeably to describe the “ability to interpret the behavior of others in terms of mental states,” they do not have identical status in emotional disorders. ToM refers to a “cold” knowledge, whereas mentalization requires the activation of relational and emotional representations, as well as processing of emotional experience (whether reflection or defense). The aim of the study was to compare the cognitive (ToM) and affective (mentalization) aspects of “understanding the behavior of others in terms of mental states” in the clinical group – consisting of patients with borderline personality organization (N = 30); and the control group (N = 30). Method: The Borderline Personality Inventory was used as a diagnostic questionnaire for the organization of personality, the Strange Stories Test was employed to measure ToM, and the Mental States Task instrument measured mentalization. Results: With respect to mentalization, different patterns of results were obtained: the activation of overwhelming mental states and primitive defenses in the clinical group; as well as the inhibition of the recognition of mental content by defenses, such as denial and suppression of emotions, in the control group. No differences were observed in ToM between groups. Conclusions: In explaining the personality organization levels, only the affective, and not the cognitive, aspects of “understanding the behavior of others in terms of mental states” are significant. People with borderline personality organization, as well as healthy individuals, use “cold” knowledge about internal states. However, the activation of relational and emotional representations triggers different mental states in both groups.
Authors and Affiliations
Dominika Górska, Monika Marszał
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP88972
- DOI -
- Views 143
- Downloads 0
Różnice w zakresie skuteczności intensywnych programów leczenia zaburzeń osobowości i nerwic. Czy warto monitorować efektywność zespołu terapeutycznego?
Cel. Sprawdzenie, czy trzy odmienne intensywne programy leczenia zaburzeń osobowości i nerwic są skuteczne w obniżaniu nasilenia objawów nerwicowych i cech osobowości nerwicowej oraz czy istnieją różnice między tymi ośro...
Between health and schizophrenia
The article, based on the literature review, presents actual concerns on prognosis and opportunity to achieve recovery in persons with schizophrenia. Catamnestic long-term studies published during last decades more often...
Wpływ leków przeciwpsychotycznych na funkcje poznawcze u pacjentów ze schizofrenią
Cel. Celem prezentowanego badania było porównanie skuteczności trzech leków przeciwpsychotycznych (ziprasidonu, olanzapiny i perazyny) w leczeniu schizofrenii oraz. porównanie poprawy funkcji poznawczych pomiędzy grupami...
Zdrowie psychiczne osób homoseksualnych i biseksualnych – przegląd badań i prezentacja zjawiska
Zagadnienia zdrowia psychicznego i psychologicznego dobrostanu osób należących do mniejszości seksualnych stały się w ostatnich latach jednym z ważkich tematów badawczych. Skupiają uwagę nie tylko psychiatrów, psychologó...
Planing disorders in men with schizophrenia and in men with localized frontal lobe lesions
Aim. Planning disorders have been observed in people with frontal lobe lesions for many decades. There’s also growing body of evidence of frontal dysfunction in people with schizophrenia. The aim of this study is to comp...