MODERN APPROACHES OF THE UNDERSTANDING OF AD-ARGUMENTS AND CRITERIA FOR THEIR ELIGIBILITY
Journal Title: Схід - Year 2016, Vol 145, Issue 5
Abstract
In this article the term "appellant argument" (ad-argument) is considered in terms of current approaches (Pragma-dialectic, informal logic, formal dialectic) on the study of the theory of argumentation. Considering the grounds on which such arguments were recognized as incorrect in argumentation for a long time. The informal nature of such arguments is the main ground for understanding them as a way of sophistic argument. In addition, it is established that critics of such arguments is possible not only by the form but also by the content. A review of the position of the subjective nature of such arguments has been performed and it has been stated that by the way of understanding the truth in terms of its communicative nature, the problem is solved by matching the arguments of the thesis based on the consent of the participants. The concept of logical consequence and the concepts of the consequence in the argumentation are being distinguished. Based on this distinction it is concluded that in contrast to the logical consequence in logic, that provides a form of communication between base and conclusions, the consequence in the argumentation is closely associated with the concept of "substantiation". The acceptability of ad-arguments is determined to be possible in case of the relationship between the thesis of a dialogue and a subject area, based on such arguments that does not belong to the subject area of the dialogue. A method of the critical issues and method of universalization of ad-arguments as a method for the verification of the relevance of such arguments are proposed.
Authors and Affiliations
Nadiia Savchenko
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP425333
- DOI 10.21847/1728-9343.2016.5(145).83849
- Views 153
- Downloads 0
Cyborg as a cyborgizated human being: the philosophical thought experiment in film 'Robocop' (2014)
The study analyzes a philosophical thought experiment conducted in film 'Robocop' (2014). The film models the situation within which a human being is transformed into a cyborg, human-robotic hybrid, and explores differen...
Theoretical and methodological principles of anti-corruption philosophical and educational concept
The article considers the reasons for the spread of corruption in higher education inUkrainefrom analytical and philosophical points of view. Nowadays the higher education ofUkraineis in critical condition. Despite the a...
PROVIDING HARMONIZATION OF FINANCIAL AND TAX ACCOUNTING OF CORPORATE INCOME: A THEORETICAL AND METHODICAL ASPECT
The purpose of the article is to explore and generalize a theoretical and methodical basis for the harmonization of financial and tax accounting of corporate income. The financial and tax accounting are characterized, a...
Methodical aspects of risk insurance companies
The article presents a diagram of the main risk groups and highlights their causes. It is stated that the insurance companies manage risk it is advisable to allocate 4 groups of assessment methods that are most suitable...
MYKOLA'S SHLEMKEVICH PHILOSOPHICAL SYSTEM AND ITS RELEVANCE TO UKRAINIANS OUTLOOK FORMATION
The philosophical inheritance of Mykola Shlemkevich remains small worked out for today. In part because his works have been scattered, published in various publications under pseudonyms, in part, because of the fact that...