Münchausen syndrome by proxy in a forensic psychiatric evaluation – the description of a case and ethical controversy
Journal Title: Psychiatria Polska - Year 2012, Vol 46, Issue 4
Abstract
Aim. Presentation of the difficulties in diagnosing Münchausen syndrome by proxy. Method. Comparison of four different conclusions in forensic psychiatric opinions issued in one case, due to the need of answering to the questions of the court, in what periods and why was the deterioration of the child’s health, in connection with an allegation that the mother has acted to his detriment. In the first medical-legal opinion the treating physician, while being the head of the ward and the person informing the police of the action against a child by the mother, recognised Münchausen syndrome by proxy. The second opinion was delivered by a psychologist, who stated that the mother distinguished the introspective attitude characterised by excessive, exaggerated accuracy, thoroughness, and did not give a unambiguous answer to the questions of the court. In the third opinion the experts accepted that the functioning of the subject does not create a threat to life and health of the child. The fourth opinion developed by the authors of this paper noted that in the analysed medical records of the childs’ hospitalisation, no arguments were found to recognise Münchausen syndrome by proxy. Results. In the conducted extended ambulant study of the subject and the analysis of the medical documentation of the 31 hospitalisations of the child showed that the improvement of the child’s health was not associated in exclusion of pushing aside the mother from the child, but was the result of the consistency of the therapeutic treatment team, the continuation and the modification of the treatment. Conclusions. In appointing the expert, the art. 196 of the Code of Criminal Procedure should be considered, which states that the expert should not be the treating doctor, because his opinion loses value impartiality. Diagnosis of Münchausen Syndrome by proxy itself stirs up numerous controversies.
Authors and Affiliations
Janusz Heitzman, Małgorzata Opio, Alfreda Ruzikowska, Anna Pilszyk
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP130182
- DOI -
- Views 106
- Downloads 0
A new role of people suffering from mental illnessesin treatment and recovery
In many countries there is a growing awareness of the significance of mutual help among patients suffering from mental illnesses. Such acts provide benefits in terms of a sense of greater activity, self-dependance, it em...
Kontekst kulturowy zaburzeń odżywiania się – badania własne
Cel badań: Celem badania jest ocena postaw i przekonań o charakterze kulturowym wśród pacjentek leczonych z powodu różnych rodzajów zaburzeń odżywiania w porównaniu z pacjentkami z rozpoznaniem depresji oraz dziewczętami...
Czynniki skuteczności jednorazowego wlewu ketaminy w depresji w przebiegu choroby afektywnej dwubiegunowej
Cel. Celem pracy była ocena skuteczności jednorazowego wlewu ketaminy oraz czynników klinicznych i biochemicznych ją warunkujących u pacjentów z depresją w przebiegu choroby afektywnej dwubiegunowej (CHAD), u których sto...
Objawy obsesyjno-kompulsyjne, tiki, stereotypie ruchowe czy dążność do zachowania stałości otoczenia? Występowanie powtarzalnych aktywności u pacjentów z całościowymi zaburzeniami rozwoju – opis przypadków
Streszczenie Jednym z kryteriów diagnostycznych charakteryzujących grupę całościowych zaburzeń rozwoju (CZR) są ograniczone i powtarzające się zachowania, które mogą przyjmować postać zaangażowania w stereotypowe zainte...
Od Redakcji
bez streszczenia