Ocena propozycji zmian przepisów art. 156 i art. 158 Kodeksu postępowania administracyjnego
Journal Title: Zeszyty Prawnicze Biura Analiz Sejmowych - Year 2018, Vol 58, Issue 2
Abstract
Amendments of the Code of Administrative Proceedings, suggested in the assessed petition, introduce an exclusion of the possibility of declaring an administrative decision invalid, if the decision has been issued without legal basis or with a gross infringement of law, after 10 years from the day the decision has been delivered or published. The proposed solution consisting of an application of the limitation period set out in Article 156 para. 2 of the Code even to such decisions issued without legal basis or with the gross infringement of law which have not been a basis for acquiring a right or expectative of a right (wider than in the Constitutional Tribunal’s judgment, ref. no. P 46/13) – stays, in the author’s opinion, in accordance with Article 2 of Polish Constitution and it could be regarded as optimally balancing the principle of the rule of law, the principle of legal certainty and the principle of the protection of legitimate expectation. Moreover, the author claims that introducing the new Article 158 para. 3 of the Code, according to which a declaration a questioned decision as invalid due to its issue without legal basis or with a gross infringement of law of issue of a decision with an infringement of law shall constitute grounds for declaration of invalidity of a decision issued on the basis of the former one, is justified.
Authors and Affiliations
Marek Szydło
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP385977
- DOI -
- Views 23
- Downloads 0
Pozbawienie partii politycznej prawa do otrzymywania subwencji – pytanie prawne Sądu Najwyższego (sygn. akt P 8/17), dotyczące ustawy o partiach politycznych
The Supreme Court’s question of law concerns conformity to the Polish Constitution of provisions providing an obligation of the National Electoral Commission to reject a political party’s financial report in any case whe...
Wydatki sztywne budżetu państwa
The article presents the definition of the legally determined state budget expenditure and the critical attitude of the science representatives to their increase in recent years. In this context, the development of these...
Opinia prawna dotycząca udzielania przez Prokuratora Krajowego (pierwszego zastępcę Prokuratora Generalnego) odpowiedzi na interpelacje i zapytania poselskie
The considerations concern the issue of legality of replies of National Prosecutor to interpellations and Deputies questions on matters related to activities of the prosecution. A reply made by the National Prosecutor is...
Ograniczenia dostępu do pornografii w internecie (kwestie braku definicji pojęcia pornografia oraz zobowiązań wynikających z konwencji genewskiej z 1923 r.)
There is no comprehensive definition of pornography in the Polish legal system. The legislator only made a fragmentary definition of pornography in relation to “child pornography”. In author’s opinion an attempt to form...
Wykazywanie w poselskim oświadczeniu o stanie majątkowym środków z tytułu świadczenia 500+, alimentów na dzieci oraz przychodu z najmu lokalu mieszkalnego
In the author’s opinion there is no legal basis for an obligation to indicate benefits from the “500+ programme” or alimony in the Deputy’s financial statement as “income obtained from employment or other gainful activit...