ON THE DISTINGUISHING OF PHILOSOPHICAL LOGIC FROM PHILOSOPHY OF LOGIC

Apply

ON THE DISTINGUISHING OF PHILOSOPHICAL LOGIC FROM PHILOSOPHY OF LOGIC

Journal Title: Вісник Черкаського університетету. Серія Філософія - Year 2015, Vol 364, Issue 31

Abstract

Introduction. The practice of the usage of the word-combinations “philosophical logic” and “philosophy of logic” in modern logical studies does not allow differentiating the notions “philosophical logic” and “philosophy of logic” because virtually the both study the similar objects with the similar methods. Purpose is to clarify the distinction between “philosophical logic” and “philosophy of logic”. Methods. For the attainment of the purpose the author uses the logical-conceptual analysis of content of notions. Results. In the course of research it turned out that in general the inability to tell the difference between philosophical logic and philosophy of logic was closely related to the mathematization of logic and the solubilization of logic within mathematics entirely, which makes senseless any use of the terms of philosophical logic and philosophy of logic because the former could be identified as a mathematical logic and the latter could be identified as a philosophy of mathematics. Conclusion and originality. To clarify the difference between philosophical logic and philosophy of logic, it is necessary to abandon the practice of considering the word-combinations “philosophical logic” and “philosophy of logic” in modern logical studies and to take hypothetically that traditional logic should be considered as a philosophical logic and classical and non-classical logics should be considered as mathematical logics. That is to say that philosophical logic is a branch of philosophy and mathematical logic is a branch of mathematics. At the same time, in a view of the understanding of logic as a study of arguments and the problems of validity and demonstrability as epistemological ones, philosophy of logic comes to be possible only when it’s considered as a philosophy which studies the essence of logic; in other words philosophy of logic attempts to explain what makes logic а logic in fact.

Authors and Affiliations

Konstantin RAYHERT

Keywords

philosophy; logic; philosophy of logic; philosophical logic; mathematical logic; traditional logic; classic logic;

EP ID EP531551
DOI -
Views 116
Downloads 0