ON THE SUBJECT OF PROOF IN CASES OF ESTABLISHMENT OF FACT OF A MAN AND A WOMAN LIVING AS A FAMILY WITHOUT BEING MARRIED
Journal Title: Вісник Одеського національного університету. Правознавство - Year 2015, Vol 20, Issue 2
Abstract
Theoretical issues concerning the so-called ",de facto marriage", has taken the attention of many prominent scientists, however, they never touched the problematic issues of the content of the application filed in the court to establish the fact of living of a woman and a man as one family without registration of marriage or the so-called ",de facto marriage",. Due to the fact that the legal fact of man and woman living as one family without registration of marriage is established in a judicial proceeding, the court, in the decision, should be guided by specific regulations (the norms of substantive and procedural law). A separate problematic issue is the definition of the subject of proof in affairs about establishing the fact of living in a family of man and woman without marriage. As the results of studying the judicial practice as the applicants (the plaintiffs in the action proceedings), and courts are usually very different and, in our opinion, often totally incorrectly formulate the operative part of the statements and decisions, respectively. This article explores examples of judicial practice in which courts have incorrectly applied norms of substantive (civil, family) and civil procedural law in cases concerning the establishment of a legal fact of living of a man and a woman as one family without registration of marriage. The author analyzes the errors and their legal consequences and provides proposals to prevent them in the future. In conclusions it is noted that the current family law operates narrative, such that do not meet the requirements of legislative techniques, concepts in this category of cases, the courts often violate the principles of application of legal norms in time. The article concludes on what it is the subject of proof in these cases and how it is necessary to formulate the requirement.
Authors and Affiliations
Y. O. Pilipenko
Keywords
Related Articles
- EP ID EP404759
- DOI -
- Views 62
- Downloads 0
CHALLENGE AS A GUARANTEE OF THE PROTECTION OF RIGHTS OF THE PARTICIPANTS OF COMMERCIAL COURTS PROCEEDINGS
Based on analysis of national procedural law the analysis of the challenge as a guarantee of defense of rights for participants is carried out in the economic legal proceedings. Direct connection of the challenge and the...
LAWSUIT AND STATEMENTOF CLAIM IN ECONOMIC LIABILITY PROCESS
The subject of research in the article are the concepts of “lawsuit”, “statement of claim” and “claim requirements” in economic legal process. The lawsuit is one of the main institutions of economic-procedural law. Thus,...
ORGANIZATIONAL AND LEGAL MECHANISM OF THE JUDICIAL IMMUNITY PRINCIPLE REALIZATION IN UKRAINE
On the modern stage of development of the democratic state it is extraordinarily actual to make a research on the topic of the judicial immunity principle realization in Ukraine. This aspect is conditioned by the circums...
THE ROLE OF NATIONAL PARLIAMENTS OF THE EUROPEAN UNION MEMBER STATES IN ENSURING THE PRINCIPLE OF SUBSIDIARITY IN THE ACTIVITIES OF THE EU INSTITUTIONS
The following article analyzes the concept, substance and nature of Principle of Subsidiarity in the European Union activity. It provides a basic overview of EU regulatory framework and international acts on this issue....
SUBMISSION REQUIREMENTS FOR INTER-STATE COMPLAINTS TO THE EUROPEAN COURT OF HUMAN RIGHTS
The article deals with requirements for the submission of inter-state complaints to the European Court of Human Rights. The elements of the inter-state complaint filed to the European Court of Human Rights are analyzed....